Reducing perceptions of discrimination (follow-up to AEARCTR-0009592)

How to cite

Ruebeck, Hannah. 2023. "Reducing perceptions of discrimination (follow-up to AEARCTR-0009592)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011806. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11806-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hannah Ruebeck*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011806
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11806-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-07-31 – 2024-02-29
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
J71, J53, J22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11806

Abstract

This pre-analysis plan documents the intended analysis for an experiment that follows up on AEARCTR-0009592. This follow-up randomized experiment examines how individuals perceive discrimination, further (relative to the original experiment) varying the methods used to hire workers and what workers know about them to understand certain mechanisms behind the original treatments that reduce perceptions of discrimination. The main outcome is the rate of perceived discrimination in each of 6 treatment arms (four of which replicate the original experiment). The follow-up will also replicate and extend the results of the original experiment on the effects of perceived discrimination on future labor supply, and, unlike the original experiment, will measure comprehension of the various treatments. This plan outlines the study design and hypotheses, outcomes of interest, and empirical specifications.

Intervention

The intervention varies how participants are hired to do a difficult proofreading and summarizing task related to scientific communication, as well as the information participants know about the hiring methods used (the original experiment used the same evaluation methods but was in the context of job assignment to one of two tasks, i.e. promotion). The follow-up experiment replicates the three methods used in the original experiment and adds one more that will extend the findings of the original study. To further understand the mechanisms behind the results of the original study, the experiment will further vary the information that workers have about the hiring methods.

Experimental design

Workers will be recruited with a screening survey and then evaluated by four hiring methods. Workers are hired or not hired to do a difficult task by one randomly-assigned mechanism. Workers who are hired are not the sample of interest. The remaining workers who were not hired by their randomly-assigned hiring method are the sample of interest. They learn about their randomly-assigned method used to determine if they were hired, answer questions about their interest in future work, and answer some survey questions.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done in an office using Stata on a computer and treatment values are uploaded to Qualtrics for each participant when they return for the experimental survey. This allows clustering, which is not possible when randomizing in Qualtrics directly. Workers are linked across surveys by their Prolific ID.
Randomization unit
Workers are grouped into random groups of 40, conditional on having quiz scores in adjacent quintiles. These groups are randomly assigned to treatment (which hiring method they will be evaluated by). Each group of 40 is sees the same historically-hired workers and, in the manager arms, manager profile.
Clusters
3960 workers are originally recruited. There are 99 groups (of 40 workers each) that are assigned together to a particular treatment. Conditional on their quintile quiz scores these workers are randomly grouped together. Some groups of 40 are randomly further paired with another to make a "super group" that sees the same historically-promoted workers, and the same demographics of their manager's if they are in the manager arms. This yields approximately 66 total clusters, with half the clusters having 80 workers and the other half having 40.
Observations
3960 workers are originally recruited. 3166 are expected to be not hired and return for the experimental session. 2850 of these are expected to be in the subsample that would have been not hired by all four hiring methods.
Arms
There are 15 or 16 groups of 40 workers assigned to each of the 6 treatment arms described above.
Primary outcomes
Perceived discrimination and future labor supply (reservation wages)
Secondary outcomes
Comprehension of the various hiring mechanisms, secondary measures of perceived discrimination, beliefs about the likelihood of being hired in the future, self-efficacy, affective well-being

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords