Hiring Decisions and Wage Inequality

How to cite

Nimczik, Jan; Pfeifer, Harald; Caliendo, Marco; Linkh, Carolin. 2023. "Hiring Decisions and Wage Inequality." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011782. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11782-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jan Nimczik* , Harald Pfeifer , Marco Caliendo , Carolin Linkh

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011782
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11782-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-07-15 – 2024-07-15
Countries
Germany ()
JEL codes
M51, J24, J31, J62
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11782

Abstract

This project sets out to add to the understanding on how managers make their hiring and wage setting decisions in German establishments. We start from the question to what extent wages and hiring decisions depend on believes about the return to individual characteristics, in particular the returns to four different types of human capital (general human capital as well as firm-, occupation-, and task-specific experience).
To address the lack of exogenous variation in human capital measures in observational data, we design a conjoint survey experiment that creates random variation in the characteristics of potential hires. We then let actual decision makers in German establishments evaluate these randomly generated candidate profiles. The conjoint survey experiment is anchored in the BIBB Cost-Benefit Survey 2022/23. We randomly vary the gender and expected performance of the potential hires as well as their general human capital, occupational experience, firm-specific experience, and task-specific experience. Based on random variation in these individual characteristics, we assess the perceived return to these different types of individual-level human capital.
Furthermore, we assess a range of personality traits of the respondents and plan to analyze the interaction between the decision makers’ personality and their choices. Finally, we aim to link the data from our questionnaire to administrative linked employer-employee data from the German Institute for Employment Research (IAB). This link will allow us to quantify the contribution of (heterogeneity in) believes about the importance of different types of HC to overall wage inequality.

Intervention

A conjoint survey experiment (choice experiment) as detailed below.

Experimental design

Within the BIBB Cost Benefit Survey 2022/23, we implement a module with survey questions and an experimental design. The BIBB Cost Benefit Survey establishment panel has ample information on the firm, on training and on industry and work characteristics. To this established survey, we add questions on the decision maker’s characteristics and preferences as well as a conjoint survey experiment. The respondents are decision makers in a representative sample of German establishments.
Respondents are first asked for their consent to link their answers to social security data from the German Institute for Labor Market Research (IAB). Second, they are asked some background questions regarding their own position and tenure within the organization, whether they have conducted an apprenticeship at the same company, their age, gender, education, and decision-making power. Then, they see an introductory text that briefly introduces the questions on preferences as well as shortly explains the relevance of preferences in this field and states that it is has become a customary practice to collect data on preferences in such settings. Fourth, they answer questions regarding preferences, in particular their risk aversion, time preferences, reciprocity, and trust in others.
Fifth, the respondents receive the instructions regarding the survey experiment where we ask them to make hypothetical hiring decision on two hypothetical applicants with different characteristics.
Finally, they see five screens with a pair of applicants on each. All applicants are characterized by six features (where the values are drawn randomly from the indicated set):
- In the firm since {0, 2, 7, 18} years
- Experience in leadership positions {0, 1, 3, 6} years
- Expected performance after the assessment center {average, good, excellent}
- Gender {male, female}
- General knowledge and skills {average, good, excellent}
- Experience in the occupation {0, 4, 10, 19} years
The possible (positive) values for the experience attributes are computed as the 25th, 50th, and 75th percentile of the respective distributions in a representative sample of German establishments, the LIAB (longitudinal model for the years 2012-2019). All values are drawn uniformly at random.
For each pair, the respondents are asked to make two decisions: Decide for one of the two applicants and enter a proposed salary for each of the applicants. Respondents can tick the box for their preferred candidate and move a slider to indicate the wage that they deem appropriate for each candidate (in percentage relation to an average wage for a leadership position of the respondent’s own organization). We randomize the order of the items as well as the order of the two tasks (wage setting and forced choice) at the respondent level.
We aim to analyze the data from the trial by estimating average marginal component effects (AMCE, see Bansak et al., 2021 and Hainmueller et al., 2014). Using our fully randomized conjoint design, we estimate linear regressions of our two primary outcomes on dummies for the different item values.
We further aim to estimate conditional AMCEs for different subgroups of respondents defined based on respondent characteristics (see our secondary outcomes). In particular, we plan to distinguish AMCEs conditional on respondents’ gender, industry, tenure at the firm, age, and educational degree. In addition, we estimate conditional AMCEs based on the respondents’ answers to the preference / personality trait questions. While parts of these heterogeneity analyses are explorative, we also aim to test a range of specific hypotheses:
- Respondents with higher levels of reciprocity are more likely to prefer internal candidates.
- Respondents with higher levels of trust are more likely to prefer external candidates.
- Respondents with lower risk tolerance are more likely to prefer internal candidates.
- Respondents in industries with higher average education levels are more likely to prefer internal candidates.
- Respondents with longer firm tenure are more likely to prefer internal candidates.
- Respondents who have conducted an apprenticeship in the same firm are more likely to prefer internal candidates.

We aim to operationalize “higher levels of …” by median splits of the sample. We measure the preference for internal vs. external candidates by the coefficients on the dummies for different values of establishment tenure.

Literature
Bansak, K., Hainmueller, J., Hopkins, D., Yamamoto, T. (2021). Conjoint Survey Experiments. In J. Druckman & D. Green (Eds.), Advances in Experimental Political Science (pp. 19-41). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/9781108777919.004
Hainmueller, J., Hopkins, D.J., Yamamoto, T. (2014). Causal Inference in Conjoint Analysis: Understanding Multidimensional Choices via Stated Preference Experiments. Political Analysis 22(1):1-30. doi:10.1093/pan/mpt024

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is carried out by a computer-based randomization.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
4,000 firms (2300 personal interviews and about 1700 web-based interviews are planned)
Observations
4,000 firms (2300 personal interviews and about 1700 web-based interviews are planned)
Arms
fully randomized conjoint analysis where all items are drawn with equal probability
Primary outcomes
Our first primary outcome of interest is the binary choice regarding which of two hypothetical applicants is preferred for a hiring/promotion decision in the eyes of a human resource manager. Our second primary outcome of interest is the choice of a wage (in relation to an average wage for a leadership position at the decision maker’s company) for each of the two applicants based on their presented profiles. The two hypothetical applicants in each choice are characterized by six different features that determine their endowment with human capital. The six different attributes are the applicants’ gender, general human capital, occupational experience, experience in leadership positions, expected performance after an assessment center, and tenure at the firm (for internal candidates). The distribution of values for the three experience measures is calculated from the Linked-Employer-Employee-Data (LIAB, longitudinal model 1975-2019) of the German Institute for Labor Market Research (IAB).
Secondary outcomes
Effect-heterogeneity concerning decision makers’ characteristics (role in their own company, tenure (in their firm and position), apprenticeship in the firm, age, gender, highest occupational degree), preferences (risk- and time preferences, positive reciprocity, trust), and industry/occupation.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords