The Impact of Behaviorally Informed Mailers on Uptake of a Cover Crop Cost-share Program

How to cite

Shang, Cecilia; Li, Jessica. 2023. "The Impact of Behaviorally Informed Mailers on Uptake of a Cover Crop Cost-share Program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011778. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11778-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cecilia Shang* , Jessica Li

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011778
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11778-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-06-05 – 2024-01-26
Countries
United States of America (Iowa)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11778

Abstract

We plan to run three randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to help increase enrollment in a cover crop cost share program for soybean and corn farmers in the Midwest. In the first two tests, we will distribute informative mailers to eligible farmers, which will be sent from a large agricultural cooperative, which is a familiar and trusted source of information for its member farmers. We will test the impact of a behaviorally-informed mailer (letter in one test, postcard in another) on enrollment in the cost-share program, and will also test whether offering a lottery incentive impacts enrollment timing. In the third test, we will investigate whether a farmer-to-farmer referral email campaign impacts enrollment in the cover crop cost-share program.

Intervention

Intervention 1: Timely mailers from a trusted messenger

We are testing the impact of behaviorally informed mailers on enrollment in a cover crop cost share program among members of a large agricultural cooperative. These member farmers make up a very small proportion of cost-share enrollees and we seek to leverage the familiarity and trust they have with their local Agricultural Cooperative to boost enrollment in the Practical Farmers of Iowa cover crop cost-share program.

Intervention 2: Farmer Network Referrals

The Practical Farmers of Iowa (PFI) has a large network of cover cropping farmers already engaged in their cover crop cost-share program. We designed a campaign to encourage farmers that enroll in the PFI cover crop cost-share program to refer their farmer neighbors and friends to the program. This intervention leverages existing farmer social networks and provides a friendly introduction to PFI’s programs from a trusted and relatable peer messenger.

Experimental design

We will be conducting three randomized controlled trials (RCTs):

RCT 1: Postcard experiment with two treatment arms and one control arm designed to evaluate the impact of postcards on enrollment in PFI's cover crop cost-share program.

RCT 2: Letter experiment with two treatment arms and one control arm designed to evaluate the impact of postcards on enrollment in PFI's cover crop cost-share program.

RCT 3: Referral program: Structured referral program with a treatment and a control arm designed to evaluate whether farmer-to-farmer referrals impact enrollment in PFI's cover crop cost-share program.

Design details

Randomization method
Intervention 1 (Timely mailers from a trusted messenger): ideas42 will conduct the randomization of eligible cooperative members using Stata. Intervention 2 (Farmer Network Referrals): Farmers will be randomized into treatment or control through an automated AirTable randomization function.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Intervention 1 (Timely mailers from a trusted messenger): 5,599 people Intervention 2 (Farmer Network Referrals): approx. 1200 people
Observations
Intervention 1 (Timely mailers from a trusted messenger): 5,599 people Intervention 2 (Farmer Network Referrals): Final count will depend on the number of enrolled farmers
Arms
Intervention 1 (Timely mailers from a trusted messenger) RCT 1 Control = 1089 people T1 = 1089 people T2: 1089 people RCT 2 Control: 457 T1: 457 T2: 457 Intervention 2 (Farmer Network Referrals) RCT 3 Control: Approximately 600 Treatment: Approximately 600 Note: These counts are approximate and based on the 1,200 farmers that enrolled in 2022. (The total sample size will depend on the number of farmers who enroll in 2023)
Primary outcomes
Enrollment in PFI’s cover crop cost share program
Secondary outcomes
Application submission date Number of Acres of fall cover crop intended to seed for 2023 # of Acres of fall cover crop seeded for 2023 Likelihood of making a referral for 2023

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords