A Cognitive View of Policing

How to cite

Dube, Oeindrila; Shah, Anuj; MacArthur, Sandy Jo. 2023. "A Cognitive View of Policing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011730. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11730-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Oeindrila Dube* , Anuj Shah , Sandy Jo MacArthur

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011730
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11730-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2019-01-24 – 2023-07-17
Countries
United States of America (Chicago, Illinois)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11730

Abstract

What causes adverse policing outcomes, such as excessive uses of force and unnecessary arrests? Prevailing explanations focus on bad actors among officers or deficient regulations and oversight. Here, we introduce a new, overlooked perspective. We suggest that the cognitive demands inherent in policing can undermine officer decision-making. Unless officers are prepared for these demands, they may jump to conclusions too quickly without fully considering alternate ways of seeing a situation. This can lead to adverse policing outcomes. To test this perspective, we created a training program that teaches officers to more deliberately consider different ways of interpreting the situations they encounter. We evaluated this training using a randomized controlled trial with 2,070 officers from the Chicago Police Department. In a series of lab assessments, we find that treated officers were significantly more likely to consider a wider range of evidence and develop more explanations for subjects’ actions. Critically, we also find that trained officers performed differently in the field: They were less likely to use force and make discretionary arrests, while their levels of activity overall remained unchanged. Moreover, trained officers were less likely to be injured on duty. Our results highlight the value of considering the cognitive aspects of policing and demonstrate the power of using behaviorally informed approaches to improve officer decision-making and policing outcomes.

Intervention

Our research team developed the Sit-D curriculum in its entirety. We drew on key concepts from the psychology of decision-making, adapting them to the policing context. We then designed numerous exercises in different formats to make it easier for officers to connect the principles of the training to the issues they face while on duty in the field.

The curriculum design was also iterative. We used a “train-the-trainer" model, instructing 31 CPD trainers on how to deliver the training. During this process, we modified the training based on extensive input from key CPD personnel, including the leadership of the Training Academy. We also modified the training based on events in the city. Notably, after widespread policing protests in Summer 2020, we added more protest scenarios to the curriculum. These steps ensured that the training was relevant and engaging to Chicago police officers.

The training consisted of four sessions that were each four hours (i.e., 16 hours total). Each session had on average 16 officers and four trainers. This ratio was important for managing the different components of each session and facilitating discussion. Typically, there were several weeks in between each session. This allowed officers to start using lessons from Sit-D while in the field and to begin subsequent sessions by debriefing how they had applied the training. Sessions consisted of a mix of classroom instruction (which included lecture and interactive activities) and scenario-based exercises. The first two sessions had more classroom instruction, while the final two sessions were entirely scenario-based exercises. Officers in the training had to take the first two sessions (which were foundational) before they could move to the final two sessions.

Experimental design

A subset of police officers from the Chicago Police Department were randomized and placed into two groups:
1. Treatment: received specialized Sit-D training
2. Control: received traditional CPD training

To gauge the causal effect of the Sit-D training, we estimate Intent to Treat (ITT) effects.

Design details

Randomization method
The units of assignment typically have four shifts (also known as watches). We stratified the randomization by unit x watch, which resulted in 92 strata. We used random assignment to select approximately half the officers in each stratum for the training group, while the other half served as the control group. In total, 1,059 officers were assigned to the Sit-D training.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is at the officer level. Our sample comprises CPD officers on active duty, who completed certain prerequisite courses. Specifically, the sample includes 2,070 active-duty police officers who have been on the job for two or more years, including those who work in one of 22 police districts in Chicago, as well as those who work in more specialized units, such as gang units, tactical teams, and area saturation teams. We refer to districts and specialized units as the units of assignment.
Clusters
1
Observations
2,070
Arms
1,059 officer assigned to training
Primary outcomes
Uses of non-lethal force; discretionary arrests; officer injuries (days off); officer activities (index)
Secondary outcomes
Considering alternative interpretations of situations, assessing ambiguous situations, coping with stress, emotion regulation, CPD use of force policy, knowledge retention from training program
Partners
Name: Chicago Police Department Partner_type: government Url: https://home.chicagopolice.org/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords