TIME PREFERENCES USING A MULTIPLE LOTTERY LIST: Validation

How to cite

Kircher, Philipp; Belot, Michele; Muller, Paul. 2023. "TIME PREFERENCES USING A MULTIPLE LOTTERY LIST: Validation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011729. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11729-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Philipp Kircher* , Michele Belot , Paul Muller

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011729
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11729-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-07-10 – 2023-12-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11729

Abstract

Belot et al (2021) lay out a theory of discount factor measurement aimed to deal with changes in income and associated background consumption over time. In many existing methods, experimental payments are assumed to be added to a “background consumption” to generate a stream of consumption, and constant background consumption is required for discount factor elicitation. Consider two individuals who have identical discount factor and identical late background consumption, but the first individuals has the same background consumption also in the early period while the second individual has less background consumption in the early period. If confronted with choices about having money early or late, the second individual has a higher marginal valuation of money early and is therefore more likely to choose the earlier payment for that reason.

Belot et al (2021) lay out a method based on choices about high-stakes lottery tickets. Applying the economic model that underlies their method to the scenario outlined in the previous paragraph shows that both individuals should be equally eager to choose the early lottery. Choices should directly reflect time preferences, rather than changes in background consumption.

This validation experiment aims to test this by triggering changes in perceived background consumption through detailed questions about near-term expenditures for some of the participants. This is intended to make them realize that their expenditures are higher than expected in the near-term, and therefore they feel that they have to reduce near-term background consumption. If they feel poor in the near-term relative to similar individuals who have not been treated, this should effect measured discount factors in the convex budget set method. Under the multiple lottery list method of Belot et al (2021), this should not happen. We intend to test this.

Intervention

We aim to induce experimentally a perceived variation in background consumption that generates changes in measured present-bias in the convex budget set (CBS) elicitation method of Andreoni and Sprenger (2012). We aim to test that this does not induce variations in measured discount factors elicited via multiple lottery lists proposed by Belot et al (2021).

Experimental design

Individuals will be randomly allocated to one of four treatment arms with 100 participants each:
(1) CBS no prompting / MLL no prompting / CBS prompting
(2) MLL no prompting / CBS no prompting / MLL prompting
(3) CBS prompting / MLL prompting
(4) MLL prompting / CBS prompting

We will test for differences between groups 1+2 and 3+4 for the first two questions. We will also test for differences between the first and third question for groups 1 and 2. We expect differences when these are measured with CBS, and not if they are measured with MLL.

The experimental design relies on our intervention to successfully alter expenditure expectations. See the full pre-analysis plan for details.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization to one of the treatment arms is done via Prolific.
Randomization unit
Sample size: 400 We will recruit participants using the on-line research platform Prolific. Eligibility criteria: ● currently residing in New York State ● with a household income below 99,999 US dollars
Clusters
There are no clusters. Each unit is one independent observation.
Observations
400 individuals
Arms
100 per treatment arm, across 4 arms
Primary outcomes
Individual discount factors elicited with the method of Convex Budget Sets (CBS) proposed by Andreoni and Sprenger (2012): especially the individual "beta" for each participant and treatment status Individual discount factors elicited with the method of Multiple Lottery Lists (MLL) proposed by Belot et al (2021): especially the individual "beta" for each participant and treatment status

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords