Which income comparisons matter to people, and how? Evidence from a large field experiment

How to cite

Xu, Xiaogeng; Metsälampi, Satu; Kirchler, Michael; Kotakorpi, Kaisa; Matthews, Peter Hans; Miettinen, Topi. 2023. "Which income comparisons matter to people, and how? Evidence from a large field experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011720. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11720-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Xiaogeng Xu* , Satu Metsälampi , Michael Kirchler , Kaisa Kotakorpi , Peter Hans Matthews , Topi Miettinen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011720
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11720-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-05-01 – 2021-07-31
Countries
Finland ()
JEL codes
D63, D8, D91, I31
Secondary IDs
The Academy of Finland, project (grant no. 332550), Finnish Centre of Excellence in Tax Systems Research / Academy of Finland (grant no. 346250), the Austrian Science Fund (FWF, project SFB F6310), Finnish Cultural Foundation (grant no. 00210723) and the Yrjö Jahnsson Foundation (grant no. 20177011)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11720

Abstract

Received wisdom holds that income rank matters for life satisfaction. In much of the literature, however, income comparisons are limited to the national population and evidence is correlational. In this paper, we investigate differences in the causal effects of rank information across reference groups. In a representative sample of mid-career Finns, we randomize individuals to receive personal rank information about educational, municipal, occupational, or age reference groups, and compare the effects, for a set of alternative welfare measures, to the standard national reference group and to a control group that receives no information. We also characterize the accuracy of rank beliefs across groups. Our data, which integrates experimental and register data, finds that rank information causes differences in satisfaction with disposable income, perceived fairness of own income, and wage satisfaction, but not life satisfaction. We also fi nd substantial variation in the effects across reference groups, with those for the national reference group both weak and insignifi cant.

Intervention

The intervention is to inform participants of the study their income rank in a reference group, i.e., how much percentage of people earning less than a participant. The reference group of the information depends on the treatment: Educational, Occupational, Municipal, Age cohort, and National.

Experimental design

The experimental design is a information provision protocol. We ran an online survey with representative sample of adult Finns at the age between 35 and 45 years old. The study was pre-registered before the data collection. In the survey, the participants were asked to assess their income ranks in each of five reference groups (Educational, Occupational, Municipal, Age cohort, National), then they were informed of their income rank in one reference group. The participants in Control group saw no information. In addition, we have treatment Choice where the participants were allowed to choose in which group that they would most like to see their income rank and they saw their rank in the chosen group. The rest of the survey for treatment Choice was the same as the other treatment groups with information. After the information, they asked questions regarding their individual well-being, just world beliefs, attitudes toward policies (redistribution, welfare, labor market, migration, etc.), attitudes toward societal issues, and real-stake tasks (how much of their earning to donate to charity and voluntary tax, and how much to purchase a lotto). In the end, they saw a summary of the survey including their payment (15 euro conditional completing the survey, 5 euro if correct assessment of income rank of a randomly chosen group).

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization to treatments was done by Statistics Finland, who were responsible for drawing the sample and sending invitations to the participants. The participants remain anonymous to the collaborators of the project.
Randomization unit
Unit of randomization is individual.
Clusters
The planned number of participants (individuals) is 7065. We also invited some participants to the non-incentivized version of the survey, but the non-incentivized participants will not be included in our analyses. The planned number of non-incentivized participants is 352.
Observations
The planned number of participants (individuals) is 7065. We also invited some participants to the non-incentivized version of the survey, but the non-incentivized participants will not be included in our analyses. The planned number of non-incentivized participants is 352.
Arms
The sample size is around 800 participants for each treatment.
Primary outcomes
We are interested in the outcomes of individual well-being (satisfaction with income, wage, job, and life, and fairness of income). We are also interested in attitudes toward different societal and political issues (trust in public agencies, attitudes to tax and labor market policies and migration policies, etc.) and social capital (perceived equal opportunities in education and job, just world beliefs, etc.). In the paper "Which income comparisons matter to people, and how? Evidence from a large fi eld experiment," we focuses on the outcomes of individual well-being and reserve other outcomes to next papers.

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. Which income comparisons matter to people, and how? Evidence from a large field experiment Authors: Xiaogeng Xu, Satu Metsälampi, Michael Kirchler, Kaisa Kotakorpi, Peter Hans Matthews and Topi Miettinen Working paper https://www.helsinkigse.fi/discussion-papers/discussion-paper-9

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords