Water Quality Challenges in Aquaculture: An RCT with Nigerian Aquafarmers

How to cite

Soderbom, Mans; Eggert, Håkan; Lancker, Kira; Chukwuone, Nnaemeka. 2023. "Water Quality Challenges in Aquaculture: An RCT with Nigerian Aquafarmers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011718. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11718-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mans Soderbom* , Håkan Eggert , Kira Lancker , Nnaemeka Chukwuone

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011718
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11718-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-07-16 – 2024-07-15
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11718

Abstract

Yields in aquaculture farming (aquafarming) vary substantially across regions and remain comparatively low in many African countries. Why this is the case is not fully understood. The premise this project is that low yields can, at least to some extent, be attributed to poor water quality. That this is a reasonable idea is supported by a large body of empirical research in various disciplines. The main hypothesis of the project is that small investments in training and technology can result in lasting and non-negligible positive effects on water quality, and consequently higher yields. To test this hypothesis, we carry out a randomized controlled trial (RCT). The setting is aquafarming in Nigeria, and the RCT will enable us to estimate the causal effects of access to training and access to a toolkit for water quality monitoring on water quality and farming outcomes. The design of the RCT will be two-armed, where the control group and the treatment groups are randomly recruited from a pool of approximately 600 (aquafarmers) based in the area Ekpan, Warri Delta State, Nigeria. The treatment group will be offered 2-3 days of training on how to assess and improve water quality, focusing on acidity and oxygen levels in particular. The training is carried out by staff at the Institute of Aquaculture Development Nigeria. The treatment group will also receive information about the quality of the water in their ponds. This information will be provided by field workers who will use a water quality control kit to obtain measures of water quality with respect to pH and oxygen level on a regular basis. All subjects will be interviewed in a baseline survey and revisited twice with 6-7 months intervals (the average rotation period of fish in the ponds). The program is implemented in partnership with University of Nigeria and Environment for Development, University of Gothenburg.

Intervention

We design an RCT where the treatment group, consisting of 300 randomly selected aquafarmers, get 2-3 days of training focusing on pH level and dissolved oxygen level as input parameters for improving survival and growth of larvae and fish. Training is carried out by the Nigerian Institute for Aquaculture Development. In addition to training, farmers in the treatment group will also receive information about the quality of the water in their ponds. This information will be provided by field workers who will use a water quality control kit to obtain measures of water quality with respect to pH and oxygen level.

Experimental design

The design is a two-armed RCT, where the control group and the treatment groups are randomly recruited from a pool of approximately 600 aquafarmers based in the area Ekpan, Warri Delta State, Nigeria. The treatment group will be offered training on how to assess and improve water quality and access to information regarding water quality.

To account for the behavior of aquafarmers before and after the intervention, the experimental design includes ex-ante, mid term and ex-post surveys for the treatment group and the control group. In our empirical analysis, observable characteristics will be used to:
• test for balance at the baseline across the treatment and control groups
• estimate the causal effects with precision
• investigate heterogeneity in outcomes across observable characteristics

In the Ekpan area there are approximately 1000 aquafarmers, most of them are organized in cooperatives which have 100-200 members. We have identified a total of 6 such cooperatives to date.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in office by a computer. The cooperative leaders in have provided us with lists of all their members. We will use the list to draw an equal number of aquafarmers for the non-treated and the treated group, including reserves that will be asked to join if any of the original subjects on the list do not want to participate or are unable to participate for any other reason.
Randomization unit
We randomize at the aquafarmer level, stratifying by cooperative. Hence each cooperative will contain farmers in the treatment group as well as farmers in the control group. There is a risk that the treatment “spills over” from farmers in the treatment group to farmers in the control group. We expect such spillovers to lead to a downward bias in the estimated average treatment effects. Hence, if we find an effect, we expect it to be a conservative estimate of the actual causal effect. Power calculations confirmed that randomizing at the level of the cooperative would not be feasible, because there are too few cooperatives.
Clusters
600 aquafarmers.
Observations
600 aquafarmers.
Arms
300 aquafarmers control, 300 treatment.
Primary outcomes
There are four main outcomes of interest: • Water quality, measured by standard indicators of pH levels and dissolved oxygen level • Total aquafarming (fish) output in kilograms per area unit • Survival rate as harvested quantity ratio in relation to quantity fingerlings initially put into the ponds. • Market price of harvested output.
Secondary outcomes
We will study a range of secondary outcomes that shed further light on mechanisms, side effects, and the distribution of effects: • Does the intervention affect adoption of new species varieties (e.g., hybrid)? • Does water quality affect pond rental price? • Heterogeneity in outcomes: What is the distribution of the main effects across households that differ with respect to gender dimensions and food security? • Does the intervention have side effects, e.g. in terms of how family labor, including child labor, is used for acquafarming?

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords