Sequential Choice and Choice Overload
How to cite
Young, Benjamin; Anufriev, Mikhail; Panchenko, Valentyn. 2023. "Sequential Choice and Choice Overload." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011690. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11690-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
There is evidence in the literature that individuals engage in sequential search (i.e. they evaluate options in a choice menu in sequence) and satisficing (i.e. they stop search after reaching a certain utility threshold). Moreover, individuals have been shown to be overloaded by too much choice and, consequently, may prefer to restrict the size of the choice set. In this work, we develop and experimentally test a theory of sequential choice that predicts that individuals may prefer smaller choice sets to larger ones. In our theory, individuals may prefer smaller menus as they lower psychological costs from leaving options unevaluated and reduce the incentives to over-search.
In our experiment, subjects play a number of rounds where a round involves choosing an option from a choice set of either size 10 or 20 via a sequential procedure. An option is comprised of a number of attributes, each with some dollar value, and the sum of these attributes is the overall dollar value of that option. There are two treatments: a simple treatment where options are comprised of three attributes and a complex treatment in which options are comprised of seven attributes. Moreover, within each treatment, there are two parts. In Part A, the size of the choice set faced is fixed while in Part B, the size of the choice set is determined by the subjects themselves. Our objective is to analyze whether the following aspects are consistent with our theory: (1) how subjects make their choice sequentially, (2) whether subjects restrict the choice set, and (3) how (1) and (2) vary with the complexity of options.
Intervention
We employ a between-subjects design. Subjects are randomly assigned at the individual level to one of two treatments: a simple treatment and a complex treatment. In the simple treatment, options require the sum of three numbers to be evaluated. Instead, in the complex treatment, options require the sum of seven numbers to be evaluated.
Experimental design
In our experiment, subjects play a number of rounds where a round involves choosing an option from a choice set of either size 10 or 20 via a sequential procedure. An option is comprised of a number of attributes, each with some dollar value, and the sum of these attributes is the overall dollar value of that option. The process by which a choice is made within a round is sequential. First, subjects compare two options from the choice set and decide which they prefer. Next, they decide whether to continue on to view an additional option to evaluate or to lock in their choice and end the round. If they end the round, then their selected option is their choice for that round. Instead, if they choose to evaluate another option, they compare their best option thus far to a new, as yet unevaluated, option. The procedure repeats until a subject either chooses to lock in an option and end the round or evaluates all available options in that round.
There are two parts to the experiment: Part A and Part B. In Part A of the experiment the size of the choice set is fixed in a given round at either 10 or 20. In Part B of the experiment, subjects are able to choose the menu size. Specifically, at the start of Part B, subjects are asked if they prefer the menu size to be 10 or 20. Their choice at this stage is implemented for all rounds in Part B.
The experiment is incentivised. In particular, we choose one of the rounds subjects participate in across both Part A and Part B. We then provide the subjects the dollar value (in AUD) of the option they chose in that round (as calculated by the sum of that options attributes). In addition, subjects are paid a show-fee of 10AUD.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.