Policy Consequences, Policy Preferences, and Moral Beliefs: The Case of Rent Control
How to cite
Agarwal, Neha; Fairris, David. 2023. "Policy Consequences, Policy Preferences, and Moral Beliefs: The Case of Rent Control." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011652. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11652-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Rent control is a price regulation to make housing more affordable for low-income tenants and is especially prominent in expensive cities. Economic theory and empirical evidence suggest that rent control may lead to undesirable economic outcomes. Most notably, rent control may reduce the quantity supplied of rental housing and beneficiaries of the controlled price may include a significant number of high-income households. Even so, rent control continues to be a popular policy tool among politicians and activists and the public debate is far from settled. We will employ a randomized control trial to ask the following question regarding rent control policy: Does learning about the economic impacts of rent control on the quantity of housing supplied and the distribution of benefits of the policy affect the political commitment of individuals towards the regulation? We will explore the moral reasons why some people support and others oppose rent control as part of public policy and ask if better information on the empirically plausible consequences of rent control influences the extent of political commitment to the policy.
Intervention
We will use a between-groups design. The main intervention is providing information on two key economic impacts of rent control. The first involves information about the effect of rent control on the quantity of rental housing supplied in the market. The second offers information regarding the low-income status of the beneficiaries of the policy. These estimates are derived from a review of the previous literature.
Additionally, we test the change in commitment to rent control policy when information is provided on the economic consequences of an alternate housing policy- namely, housing vouchers- on the two economic outcomes (i.e., quantity of rental units and targeting).
Experimental design
We plan to conduct an online experiment programmed in Qualtrics and administered using Prolific--- a common economics online research platform.
We first start by eliciting information about the degree of respondents’ support or opposition to rent control. Respondents will be provided with information on the changes in the quantity of rental housing stock because of rent control and what proportion of rental housing is occupied by low-income households. The estimates will correspond to three values: low, medium, and high. These estimates are randomly assigned to the respondents in both surveys. After each piece of information given we will ask for their support or opposition to the rent control policy.
We will also provide information about the impact of housing vouchers on the quantity of rental housing and the income distribution of beneficiaries in comparison to rent control and elicit respondents’ preferences between rent control and housing vouchers. The information comparing vouchers to rent control on the two aspects of the quantity of housing supplied and targeting will also be randomly allocated to the respondents. Participants will also be asked a number of demographic questions, and some questions about their beliefs and values.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.