Effects of Enrichment Tutoring on 1st and 2nd Grade Students’ Oral Reading Fluency

How to cite

Cortes, Kalena; Loeb, Susanna. 2023. "Effects of Enrichment Tutoring on 1st and 2nd Grade Students’ Oral Reading Fluency." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011646. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11646-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kalena Cortes* , Susanna Loeb

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011646
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11646-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-08-16 – 2023-06-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11646

Abstract

The study design is a randomized control trial that compares the reading proficiency of students that receive the 1:1 high dosage tutoring support plus the enrichment tutoring to that of students that receive only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring support. The tutoring program began in August 2022 in 8 schools; 14 first grade and 5 second grade classrooms (19 classrooms in total). This study involves 255 students enrolled in 19 classrooms identified by the school district who agreed to participate. Approximately half of the students in each classroom are randomly assigned to receive the enrichment tutoring along with the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (treatment group, N=131) and approximately half of the students were assigned to receive only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (control group, N=124).

Intervention

The Intervention: The study design is a randomized control trial (RCT) that compares the reading proficiency of students that receive the 1:1 high dosage tutoring support plus the enrichment tutoring to that of students that receive only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring support.

The tutoring program began in August 2022 in 8 schools; 14 first grade and 5 second grade classrooms (19 classrooms in total). This study involves 255 students enrolled in 19 classrooms identified by the school district who agreed to participate. Approximately half of the students in each classroom are randomly assigned to receive the enrichment tutoring along with the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (treatment group, N=131) and approximately half of the students were assigned to receive only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (control group, N=124).

The RCT is undertaken to determine the effects, if any, of enrichment tutoring combined with 1:1 high dosage tutoring on students’ reading proficiency. Two hypotheses will be tested,

(1) Null Hypotheses: Students reading proficiency on literacy outcomes are equal between two groups, one receiving the 1:1 high dosage tutoring plus enrichment tutoring (treated group) and one receiving only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (control group).

(2) Alternative Hypotheses: Students who receive the enrichment tutoring along with the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (treated group) will make greater gains on literacy outcomes than students receiving only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (control group).

Random assignment to treatment and control groups will create baseline equivalence of the two groups or no systematic differences at baseline, thereby reducing bias. To strengthen internal validity, members of the two groups will be similar in age, grade level, enrollment in classrooms, and performance level in literacy.

Research Question: The purpose of this research is to determine the impact of the enrichment tutoring on students’ 1st and 2nd grade reading gains. Thus, this RCT study aims to address the following research question: What is the effect, if any, of the enrichment tutoring combined with the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (treated group) on students’ reading proficiency compared to students receiving only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring (control group)?

Randomization: To assign students to one of the experimental conditions, we will employ a student-level randomized control trial design. Specifically, within each classroom (N=19), we randomly assigned half of the students to the treatment group (1:1 high dosage tutoring plus enrichment tutoring) and half of the students to the control group (only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring). The total randomization sample consist of 255 students enrolled in first and second grade classrooms: 131 students in the treated group and 124 students in the control group.

Experimental design

To assign students to one of the experimental conditions, we will employ a student-level randomized control trial design. Specifically, within each classroom (N=19), we randomly assigned half of the students to the treatment group (1:1 high dosage tutoring plus enrichment tutoring) and half of the students to the control group (only the 1:1 high dosage tutoring). The total randomization sample consist of 255 students enrolled in first and second grade classrooms: 131 students in the treated group and 124 students in the control group.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer randomization
Randomization unit
Student-level randomization within each classroom
Clusters
255 students
Observations
255 students
Arms
131 students in the treated group; 124 students in the control group.
Primary outcomes
Grades (1 and 2): end-of-year reading/literacy outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords