Stigma and Social Safety Net Program Participation
How to cite
Pukelis, Kelsey; Heath, Alice; Holcomb, Michael. 2023. "Stigma and Social Safety Net Program Participation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011634. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11634-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Stigma surrounding safety net programs may inhibit take-up among eligibles (Moffitt 1983; Currie 2006) and impose utility costs on individuals already receiving benefits (Kleven & Kopczuk; Anders & Rafkin 2022). In this project, we conduct a survey experiment to investigate the nature of stigma associated with the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP or food stamps). We collect respondents’ attitudes about SNAP and perceived judgement of SNAP status among different social groups. We compare individuals’ perceptions about social judgments to the full distribution of respondents’ attitudes to see if perceptions are accurate, particularly for low-income respondents who may be eligible for SNAP. In addition, we test interventions that either reframe SNAP benefits as a tool for economic mobility or inform respondents that one household’s participation decision will not affect whether others can receive benefits. We will measure the effect of the interventions on indices of survey responses describing the degree of stigma perceived by potential recipients and stigmatizing attitudes held by the general population. We will also measure the effect of the intervention on a relevant action: filling out a SNAP eligibility screener. Our study will contribute to the literature on stigma and take-up of safety net programs, focusing on the application decision margin for a highly stigmatized program.
Intervention
There are three intervention groups and one control group. The control group will receive no intervention during the survey.
Experimental design
Our sample includes survey respondents from Prolific. The survey respondents will answer a series of questions at baseline. Demographic questions asked at baseline include household size, state of residence, and prior SNAP participation status. We also collect respondents’ general preferences for redistribution and a survey module designed to capture an individual's propensity to give socially desirable answers. At baseline, we also collect respondents’ perceptions about features of the SNAP program and recipient population. Key factual questions are incentivized to encourage respondents to report their best guess.
The respondents will then be randomly assigned into one of the four main treatment arms, stratified by prior SNAP participation status. There are four blocks or strata: current SNAP recipient, past SNAP recipient, never a SNAP recipient, or missing SNAP status. Conditional on the prior SNAP participation group, respondents are randomly assigned into one of the four treatment arms with equal probability. Respondents in each treatment group are shown only one piece of information described in the interventions section above; those in the control group are shown no information.
Then, survey respondents will answer the remaining survey questions. Questions provided after the intervention include the outcome questions described above and additional demographic questions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.