Improving Parental Stimulation in a childcare setting: a cluster-randomised controlled trial in marginalized urban areas in Argentina

How to cite

Jervis, Pamela; Alasino, Enrique; Trias, Julieta; Vargas, María José. 2023. "Improving Parental Stimulation in a childcare setting: a cluster-randomised controlled trial in marginalized urban areas in Argentina." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011613. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11613-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Pamela Jervis* , Enrique Alasino , Julieta Trias , María José Vargas

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011613
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11613-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-06-21 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Argentina (Mendoza)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11613

Abstract

The goal of preschool education is to support children’s cognitive, physical, and socioemotional development, providing a safe and nurturing environment for young children to learn and interact with their peers. However, in 2022 Mendoza, Argentina, the provincial oral fluency census showed that 59% of 2nd graders are at a critical level and 19% at a basic level, while only 22% are at or above expected. Recognising the lack of access to public preschools and additionally the lack of motivation among parents to send their child to preschools, the Dirección General de Escuelas de la Provincia de Mendoza launched the “Nutrition Language Program” (NLP) to provide tools to ‘vulnerable’ families. The study aims to measure the causal effect in the teacher-led parent training on child development (cognitive, language, motor, and socioemotional skills), child development knowledge and parenting behavior (on aspects such as parenting practices, role efficacy and satisfaction, and parenting competencies), and level of well-being. The evaluation will test if these programme improvements lead to an increase in child development outcomes using a cluster randomised control trial.

Intervention

"The intervention will be stratified at the department level in Mendoza, Argentina. 9 departments have been selected using purposive sampling out of the 18 total of Mendoza. The selection of departments was based on the criteria that the district must have had public childcares (SEOS) that are in marginalized areas and that run classrooms of children aged in average 2 years old. From the 9 departments selected, 78 SEOS were eligible to participate in the study, of which equal number of SEOS will be assigned to 2 arms. The intervention will be randomised at the SEOS level. Randomization will be done on the computer using Stata. There are two study arms: 1) Treatment Arm receiving ""Language Nutrition Program"" (38 SEOS): The SEOS in the treatment arm will receive parenting group session in the SEOS only for classrooms of children aged in average 2 years old. In average, SEOS have 2 classrroms of children aged 2 years old and all these classrooms will receive the treatment. Of those, 19 SEOS in the treatment group will be randomly assigned to receive messages in addition to the group sessions, of which 10 will be assigned with messages only to the primary caregiver, and the other 9 to the primary caregiver and the primary caregiver's partner. The other 19 SEOS will be the message control group (receiving group sessions only). The treatment is planned to last 18 months (July 2023 to December 2024).
2) Control Arm receiving the statuo quo (38 SEOS): The parents in the control arm will receive the statuo quo services provided by the SEOS."

Experimental design

"The intervention will be stratified at the department level in Mendoza, Argentina. 9 departments have been selected using purposive sampling out of the 18 total of Mendoza. The selection of departments was based on the criteria that the district must have had public childcares (SEOS) that are in marginalized areas and that run classrooms of children aged in average 2 years old. From the 9 departments selected, 78 SEOS were eligible to participate in the study, of which equal number of SEOS will be assigned to 2 arms. The intervention will be randomised at the SEOS level. Randomization will be done on the computer using Stata. There are two study arms: 1) Treatment Arm receiving ""Language Nutrition Program"" (38 SEOS): The SEOS in the treatment arm will receive parenting group session in the SEOS only for classrooms of children aged in average 2 years old. In average, SEOS have 2 classrroms of children aged 2 years old and all these classrooms will receive the treatment. Of those, 19 SEOS in the treatment group will be randomly assigned to receive messages in addition to the group sessions, of which 10 will be assigned with messages only to the primary caregiver, and the other 9 to the primary caregiver and the primary caregiver's partner. The other 19 SEOS will be the message control group (receiving group sessions only). The treatment is planned to last 18 months (July 2023 to December 2024).
2) Control Arm receiving the statuo quo (38 SEOS): The parents in the control arm will receive the statuo quo services provided by the SEOS."

Design details

Randomization method
Computer on Stata
Randomization unit
SEOS
Clusters
78 SEOS
Observations
1521 children
Arms
Treatment=38 SEOS, Control=38 SEOS
Primary outcomes
Early childhood development (Cognition and Language) using Bayley-III and MacArthur
Secondary outcomes
Motor skills using CREDI and ECDI UNICEF, Socio-emotional development using CREDI and SDQ, Teachers' motivation and job satisfaction, Teachers' burnout and self-efficacy, Mental health, Primary caregivers' self-efficacy, mental health and childhood development knowledge (using the Knowledge of Infant Development Inventory or the Survey of Parents Expectations and Knowledge), Primary caregivers' parenting practices and Home learning environment using FCI and adapted versions of HOME. Preschool quality using the MIRAr and preschool structural conditions using a list of characteristics.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords