The role of experience and complementarity in technology adoption: Evidence from long-range monsoon forecasts
How to cite
Kelley, Erin. 2023. "The role of experience and complementarity in technology adoption: Evidence from long-range monsoon forecasts." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011594. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11594-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Adoption of profitable technologies in developing countries is notoriously low. In this project, we study the extent to which (A) experience and (B) complementarity with other technologies can improve take-up and benefits from a novel risk coping technology: long-range forecasts of the onset of the Indian summer monsoon. We use a cluster-randomized trial to experimentally test (1) whether demand for, and subsequent behavior change in response to, a forecast is stronger if a household is receiving a forecast for the second year in a row as compared with a household receiving the forecast for the first time; (2) whether demand for index insurance is stronger if the purchasing household will also receive a forecast; and (3) whether farmers respond to these products as complements or substitute.
Intervention
In 2022 we randomized the provision of forecasts to farmers, and benchmarked the impact of forecasts against that of insurance. Specifically, we worked in 250 villages, assigning 100 villages to receive forecasts, 50 to receive insurance, and 100 to be part of the control group. We selected 5 farmers within each village to be part of our sample. In 2023, we ran the study again. We continued to work in the same 250 villages, but we changed our experimental design. First we assigned half of the control group to receive forecasts for the first time, and we assigned half of the insurance group to receive forecasts an} insurance. The original 100 villages assigned to forecasts continued to receive forecasts for a second year.
Experimental design
In Year 1 we randomized 250 villages (sampling 5 farmers each) in Telangana into one of two treatment arms and a control group. In treatment 1 villages (100), farmers received forecasts, while in treatment 2 villages (50), farmers received insurance as a benchmark. Comparing Treatment 1 to control identifies the impact of forecasts relative to the control group. Comparing Treatment 2 to Treatment 1 identifies the impact of insurance relative to the forecast group, and allows us to benchmark the impact of the forecast relative to another well-known risk-mitigation technology.
We adjust our experimental design in the next agricultural season to understand 1) whether the provision of forecasts has a larger impact when farmers receive them a second time, 2) whether the provision of forecasts affects insurance take-up, and 3) whether forecasts and insurance act as complements or substitutes. First, we provide half of the Year 1 control group with access to forecasts. Second, we provide half of the insurance group from year 1 with access to forecasts. We can make three interesting comparisons with this design. First, we can compare farmers who receive forecasts two years in a row to those who receive it for the first time. This identifies the impact of receiving forecasts two years in a row, and establishes whether farmers who trust the forecast more make larger adjustments to their agricultural practices. Second, we can compare farmers who receive insurance to those who receive forecasts and insurance, to identify how the forecast offer affects farmers’ demand for insurance. Third, we can compare farmers who receive forecasts \emph{and} insurance to those who receive forecasts \emph{or} insurance to identify whether farmers treat the products as complements or substitutes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.