Impact of digital advisory services on behavior change, sustainable land management (SLM) practices adoption, and household welfare: Experimental evidence from Uganda and India

How to cite

Maina, Charles; Mulungu, Kelvin; Suresh, Roopa; Kassie, Menale; Tschopp, Maurice. 2024. "Impact of digital advisory services on behavior change, sustainable land management (SLM) practices adoption, and household welfare: Experimental evidence from Uganda and India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011589. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11589-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Charles Maina* , Kelvin Mulungu , Roopa Suresh , Menale Kassie , Maurice Tschopp

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011589
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11589-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-09-01 – 2025-03-10
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11589

Abstract

In many Global South countries, the efficacy of in-person extension systems in providing tailored and timely agricultural information to smallholders and fostering their adoption is constrained by various factors. These include the high cost of reaching farmers in remote villages, limited mobility and interaction of agents with farmers, and the poor delivery of context-specific information. Digital advisory services (DAS) have advanced to overcome these challenges and improve upon the existing face-to-face extension model by reducing the cost of linking farmers with extension officers, delivering tailored and timely advice, and reducing inequalities in access to information, knowledge, and technologies.

This study is a four-arm cluster (village) randomized controlled trial aimed at evaluating the impact of three DAS delivery models on three outcomes: awareness and knowledge of SLMPs, adoption of SLM practices, and their impact on crop productivity. This study uses an agricultural information app, farmbetter, as a proxy for DAS. The study will be conducted in Uganda and India. The interventions are as follows: (1) Agent-only treatment, where the extension agent will use the app and deliver the information to farmers; (2) self-service treatment, where the farmers will use the app independently; and (3) hybrid treatment, where both the farmers and the extension agents will use the app. The unit of randomization is a village in both countries. There are 40 clusters (villages) per arm, and the outcomes will be assessed in 12 households per village in Uganda and about 11 households per village in India. The control villages will be at least 50 km away from the treatment to reduce information spillover. Baseline data will be collected at the beginning of the study and end-line data will be collected after three growing seasons to measure the impact of DAS on the three outcomes.

Findings will explore the most effective DAS delivery approach among the three. Effectiveness will be measured based on the effect on the adoption of SLMPs and the impact on agricultural productivity. This will contribute to the design of DAS in developing countries.

Intervention

The intervention for this study involves access to digital advisory services through a mobile-based application called "farmbetter app". This application is customized into three different models that will provide access to digital advisory services (DAS) to farmers. The three models include, Agent-based model, Self-service model, and Hybrid model which form three treatments for this study. Under the Agent-based model, only the extension/village based agents will be able to download the "farmbetter app" to access DAS and train farmers. Under the Self-service model, only farmers will be able to download the app and use it independently to access DAS, while Hybrid model, both the extension agents and the farmers will be able to download the app and share the information together.

Experimental design

The study is a four-arm cluster randomized controlled trial with a total of 160 clusters (or villages) in each country (i.e., Uganda and India). These clusters are formed from the three DAS delivery models customized in the "farmbetter app" (i.e., Agent-based model, Self-service model, and Hybrid model) and a control group. Forty clusters (or villages) are randomly allocated to each treatment and the control with an allocation ratio of 1:1:1:1.

Before the actual randomization of farmers to various treatment groups and control group, a listing exercise of farmers within the selected villages was conducted in Uganda and India. For a farmer to qualify, he/she must be involved in farming (agriculture and allied activities) and own a smartphone (either individually or as a family). The following preliminary information was collected during farmers’ listing exercise; name of the farmer, age, gender, contact number, type of mobile ownership, digital literacy and common crops grown. Once the list was obtained, the households were then randomized into three treatments and a control group.

The trial is expected to run for three growing seasons. Two long seasons and one short season in Uganda, and two wheat seasons and one rice season in India. The impact of DAS delivery models will be evaluated through two main surveys at the start (baseline) and end-line with continuous phone surveys at the end of each season.

Baseline data was collected between August-September 2023 for Uganda and India. The end-line survey will be conducted between December 2024 and February 2025. Each interview will take approximately 1 hour.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was done using a computer following farmers' listing exercise in Uganda and India.
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
160 villages
Observations
In Uganda: 1,920 households while in India: 1,760 households
Arms
In both Uganda and India; 40 villages for agent based model, 40 village for self-service model, 40 village for hybrid model and 40 village for control.
Primary outcomes
1. Awareness and knowledge of sustainable land management practices. 2. Adoption of sustainable land management practices. 3. Crop yields (i.e., maize for Uganda; wheat and rice for India).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords