What is “Local”? A Lab-in-the-Field Experiment on Urban-Rural Differences in Willingness to Pay for Different Definitions of Local Food
How to cite
Huang, Chiu-Lin; Reed, Josh; Vecchi, Martina; Liu, Yizao; Jaenicke, Edward. 2023. "What is “Local”? A Lab-in-the-Field Experiment on Urban-Rural Differences in Willingness to Pay for Different Definitions of Local Food." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011587. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11587-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this study, we aim to investigate the variations in willingness to pay for local and non-local potato chips among supermarket shoppers across different urban-rural landscapes, and the influence of different definitions of "local" on their purchasing decisions. We will conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment in Pennsylvania, focusing on supermarket shoppers in parking lots outside supermarkets situated in urban and rural areas. This approach will allow us to target supermarket shoppers and capture a diverse range of participants from various urban-rural landscapes.
Intervention
In order to investigate (i) variations in the willingness to pay for local and non-local potato chips among supermarket shoppers across different urban and rural landscapes, and (ii) how different definitions of local affect their willingness to pay, we will set up a stand to recruit participants in supermarket parking lots in two different Pennsylvania locations, one urban and one rural. The study is open to those who meet the following criteria: are interested in buying potato chips and willing to join the experiment, are 18 years of age or older, and do not have a known allergy or intolerance to any ingredient typically found in potato chips. Qualified participants will be directed to a table near the recruitment site for the study.
Upon completing the study, participants will receive a $10 grocery gift card for compensation and $15 in cash for participating in a potato chip purchasing game at the end. Participants will complete a survey on tablets using the Qualtrics platform.
In the survey, participants will be randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups: one group will be informed that local potato chips are those produced within Pennsylvania, and the second group will be told that local potato chips are those primarily sold within Pennsylvania. We will explain the Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) method for willingness to pay on the survey screen, emphasizing that their indicated willingness to pay is not hypothetical and that the purchasing game is based on how much they indicate they are willing to pay. Participants will then be asked to indicate their willingness to pay for local and non-local potato chips based on the provided definition of "local". The price range for the chips is presented in increments of $0.10, from $0 to $15. Following this, participants will complete a brief survey about their attitudes towards local food, shopping habits, and demographic information. They will then go through the compensation process. Participants will be compensated with a $10 grocery gift card for attending and completing the experiment, plus $15 in cash for participating in a purchasing game. In this game, they may use part of the cash to purchase potato chips at a randomly selected price.
A drawing-like game will be used to determine whether a purchase is made. Two boxes, one for potato chip types and one for selling prices, will be presented. A potato chip type (local or non-local) will be randomly selected, followed by a selling price ranging from $0.5 to $15 in increments of 50 cents. If the participant's stated maximum willingness to pay for the chosen potato chips is equal to or greater than the randomly selected price, they can purchase the chips at the selected price using part of their $15 in cash. If their maximum WTP is lower than the selling price, no transaction will occur, and the participant will receive a $10 grocery gift card and $15 in cash, but no potato chips.
To prevent bias from brand preference, we will use two types of unbranded potato chips labeled as "local" and "non-local" in the game. The potato chips will be packaged in non-transparent bags to preclude brand identification .
Experimental design
To test the influence of different definitions of "local," participants in this study will be randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups: (1) one group includes those told that local potato chips are produced in Pennsylvania, and (2) a second group includes those informed that local potato chips are primarily sold in Pennsylvania. Participants, who live in diverse landscapes, will be asked to indicate their willingness to pay for local and non-local potato chips based on the definition of local provided to them.
Once given these definitions, participants will indicate their willingness to pay for local and non-local potato chips based on the definitions, and then complete a short demographic survey.
Specifically, participants will denote how much they're willing to pay for a bag of local and non-local potato chips of the same flavor and approximately the same weight. Prices range from $0 to $15, in increments of $0.10. Given individual preferences, it is acceptable if participants choose not to pay anything for certain types of potato chips, which could indicate a strong dislike for that specific type. However, to avoid an excess of invalid responses (instances where the participant is unwilling to pay for any type of potato chips), we will inform potential participants at experiment locations about the opportunity to purchase potato chips and earn extra money.
Through a short survey, demographic information such as gender, race, age, food shopping habits, and attitudes toward local food will be collected. As we also aim to examine rural-urban differences, we will collect participants' addresses to ensure a diverse sample. No names will be collected, and all data will be analyzed anonymously and reported statistically.
Participants will use tablets to complete the survey on Qualtrics. The experiment will be conducted outside supermarkets in in two different locations, one urban and one rural, in Pennsylvania.
Participants will receive a $10 grocery gift card for attending and completing the experiment, along with $15 in cash for participating in a purchasing game. This game enables them to buy potato chips at a randomly selected price. The Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) method will be used to gauge participants' willingness to pay. Participants will be taught this method before they state their willingness to pay for chips in the survey. At the end of the experiment, participants may purchase one type of potato chip if the selling price is lower or equal to their stated maximum willingness to pay.
To determine whether a purchase occurs, a drawing-like game will be played. Two boxes will be provided with marked balls: one for potato chip types (local or non-local) and one for selling prices (ranging from $0.50 to $15 in increments of 50 cents). If the participant's stated maximum willingness to pay for the drawn potato chip type is greater than or equal to the drawn selling price, the participant will buy the potato chips at the selling price. Otherwise, no transaction will occur.
Two types of potato chips, without visible branding and labeled as "local potato chips" and "non-local potato chips", will be used to prevent brand preference from influencing decisions. Potato chips sold during the purchasing game will be provided in non-transparent bags to further prevent brand identification. All potato chips will be of the same flavor and approximately the same size and will be purchased from supermarkets.
The main goal of this study is to investigate whether the willingness to pay for local and non-local potato chips among supermarket shoppers varies based on different urban-rural landscapes, and whether different definitions of local affect these shoppers' willingness to pay for local potato chips. In addition to comparing the willingness to pay across the two treatment groups and examining variations between urban and rural landscapes, we also ask participants' personal definitions of local food through specific survey questions. This will allow us to explore whether these definitions vary across different landscapes. Through our research, we aim to deepen our understanding of consumer behavior and identify the factors that influence their willingness to pay for local products.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.