Impact of PES firm-targeted prospection and employment services

How to cite

Paul-Delvaux, Louise; Crépon, Bruno; Devoto, Florencia; Hanna, Rema. 2023. "Impact of PES firm-targeted prospection and employment services." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011579. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11579-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Louise Paul-Delvaux* , Bruno Crépon , Florencia Devoto , Rema Hanna

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011579
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11579-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-01-01 – 2024-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
JO8, J2, J16, J23, J24, J68
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11579

Abstract

Over the past two decades, Morocco’s growth has been accompanied by low job creation, and labor market conditions remained characterized by persistent unemployment, low job quality, and exclusion of certain groups such as the youth and women. The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated these challenges. Given this context, it is critical to better understand how public employment services (PES) can help stimulate job creation, create longer-lasting job matches and increase access to job opportunities for all. In this study, we partner with the Moroccan Public Employment Agency – l'Agence Nationale de Promotion de l'Emploi et des Compétences, (Anapec) – to assess the impact of offering hiring support to firms on a number of relevant labor market indicators. In particular, we are evaluating an intervention that aims to alleviate some of the information frictions firms face in accessing PES services and to determine whether a higher take-up of three types of services – wage subsidy, training subsidy, and screening services – can boost labor demand. We plan to rely on administrative and survey data to measure whether the treatment helps stimulate labor demand and increase job creation. We also use this data to explore mechanisms through the types of PES services that are used and the quality of the newly created vacancies.

Intervention

The primary experiment estimates the impact of having a PES caseworker (i) promote PES services to employers and (ii) assist them with all their follow-up needs. We will measure this impact on a range of indicators, including their willingness to engage with PES caseworkers, their demand for the proposed PES services, and their overall labor demand (number of new hires and their characteristics)

As part of our baseline, we also implemented a survey experiment. Prior to sending the online surveys to firms and doing follow-up calls to fill out the survey, the research team randomly assigned firms into four groups: three treatment groups that received additional information and details about one of the three main PES services (subsidized contracts program; subsidized training and screening services); a control group that only received the basic email and invitation to fill out the baseline survey.

Experimental design

Our primary experiment estimates the impact of having a PES caseworker (i) promote PES services to employers and (ii) assist them with all their follow-up needs. We randomly assigned firms in our samples to one of these (same-size) two groups:
*Treatment group: firms are actively being prospected and assisted by a PES caseworker.
*Control group: PES caseworkers don’t actively contact them but, if employers in this group contact the PES on their own initiative, they will still have access to all the PES services.

We will measure the impact of this intervention on a range of indicators, including their willingness to engage with PES caseworkers, their demand for the proposed PES services, and their overall labor demand (number of new hires and their characteristics). These indicators will be measured both via an endline survey and administrative data.

As part of our baseline, we also implemented a secondary survey experiment. Prior to sending the online surveys to firms and doing follow-up calls to help them fill out the survey, the research team randomly assigned firms into four groups, three of them received additioanl information about a specific PES program (subsidized wages; subsidized training and screening services) and a control group only received the basic invitation to answer our survey.

Design details

Randomization method
Our randomization for the survey experiment was done in Stata using the administrative data from the Moroccan PES. Our randomization for the main experiment was done in Stata using the sample of firms that responded to our baseline survey. All codes will be made public at publications.
Randomization unit
Our research protocol is based on two orthogonal randomizations at the firm level. For the survey experiment, we randomize the information firms received about one of the PES services. For the main intervention, we randomize the follow-up calls with PES caseworkers at the firm level among the ones that responded to our baseline survey. We stratified by (i) the Anapec local agencies that will conduct the prospection and follow-up PES; (ii) a dummy variable equals to 1 if a firm reported an hiring need at baseline; (iii) a categorical variable indicating whether the firm had contact with the Moroccan PES in the last two years; are at risk of being contacted after the start of the intervention because of PES administrative follow-ups; no recent contact and no risk of near future contact. For our secondary experiment, we also run the randomization on a computer. We randomized our secondary intervention at the firm level and stratified along the two following dimensions: (i) size of firms; (ii) sector of activity.
Clusters
The design is not clustered.
Observations
8,000 firms
Arms
4,000 firms in the treatment group and 4,000 in the control group for the main experiment.
Primary outcomes
Outcomes from PES Administrative Data : *Type and intensity of contact with PES caseworkers *Use of PES services: take-up of the main PES programs including subsidized training (FCE), wage subsidies (Idmaj & Tahfiz), and screening services. *Number and type of job postings on the PES website. *Number and characteristics of applicants for job descriptions posted by firms included in our sample. * *Number and characteristics of hired workers for job descriptions posted by firms included in our sample. Outcomes from Social Security Data (conditional on access) : *Number of newly hired workers. *Wages of newly hired workers. *Characteristics of newly hired workers: age, gender, tenure in the formal sector. *Share of newly hired workers that come from the PES pool (combining the two sources of data). Endline Survey Outcomes (conditional on funding): *Time spent and perceived challenges during the recruitment process. *Subjective assessment of workers recruited via Anapec. *Perception of the PES and its services. *Knowledge about the PES services. *Number and characteristics of hired workers (if administrative data is not made available)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords