The Academic Advising Program was introduced at the University of Melbourne in 2020. The goal of this program is to build connections between students and academics so that students can receive personalized guidance and support while navigating the opportunities and challenges of university. The current system randomly assigns students to academics. However, a great amount of feedback has indicated that participants care about whom they are assigned to. A better match between students and academics can make it easier for academics to provide useful and relevant advice and improve students' engagement and participation in the program. In this project, we aim to tackle this problem using insights from the matching theory and market design.
Intervention
We designed two matching algorithms to match advisors and students in the Academic Advising program.
Experimental design
The experimental design consists of two treatments. Each treatment includes a preference elicitation survey, a matching algorithm, and the collection of outcome variables
Design details
Randomization method
Each participant will be randomly assigned to one of the two treatments. We will use Qualtrics to conduct randomization and set the randomizer to equalize participation in each treatment.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Our target sample size is 1000 students.
We have limited control over the sample size because all members of the eligible cohort will be invited to participate. It is difficult to predict the exact sample size because (1) it is difficult to predict the take-up rate as the Office of Academic Advising has not done any programs like this in the past; (2) it is difficult to predict how many cohorts we can include in the study as this is determined by the Office of Academic Advising on the faculty and the university level.
Observations
1000 students
Arms
1000 students treatment 1, 1000 students treatment 2
Primary outcomes
1. Submitted preferences: the number and range of selected characteristics, the ranking and score of selected characteristics.
2. Student welfare (mean and distribution) based on their (1) submitted preferences, (2) the interactions with the Academic Advising program (including meeting attendance, responses to the satisfaction surveys, etc.).
Secondary outcomes
1. Student welfare in correlation with demographic variables.
2. Long-term impact: students' academic performance and outcomes (individual study plans, subject completions, time-to-graduation, and participation in extracurricular activities).
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.