Probabilistic Weather Forecasts and Agricultural Decision Making in Rural India
How to cite
Surendra, Vaishnavi; Cole, Shawn; Harigaya, Tomoko. 2023. "Probabilistic Weather Forecasts and Agricultural Decision Making in Rural India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011526. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11526-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Weather uncertainty is a significant source of agricultural production risks, and is increasingly salient in the context of climate change. Short- to medium-range weather forecasts could help farmers optimize the timing of agricultural practices, increasing returns to agricultural investment. However, smallholder farmers in most parts of the developing world do not have access to highly localized, accurate forecasts, nor are forecasts customized to convey weather conditions relevant for agricultural decision-making. In this study, we investigate whether accurate, relevant-for-context, probabilistic, medium-range weather forecasts can aid farmer decision-making through a lab-in-the-field experiment. We will analyze whether climate change salience, probability training, prior luck impact choices in the experiment and willingness-to-pay for weather forecasts.
Intervention
Farmers are randomly assigned to one of the following groups: (1) climate change salience information treatment; (2) probability training and climate change salience information treatments; (3) control.
1. The climate change salience information treatment involves farmers watching a video describing changing weather patterns globally and locally, and the impact it has on coffee farming.
2. The probability training information treatment involves farmers watching a probability training video.
3. In round 1 of the experiment, farmers will receive a few hypothetical scenarios that involve choosing a location with specific weather conditions out of two locations, for which they see weather forecasts. Once a location is chosen, farmers will indicate their confidence in their choice ('points-at-stake'), and then in-experiment-round weather will be realized. Farmers’ payoffs will depend on the realized weather.
4. In round 2 of the experiment, farmers will receive a few hypothetical cultivation practice-related scenarios that involve choosing an action following a weather forecast. Once an action is taken, in-experiment-round weather will be realized. Farmers’ payoffs will depend on the realized weather.
5. Finally, we will elicit farmers’ willingness-to-pay for accurate, customized, probabilistic weather forecasts.
Experimental design
We will recruit small- and medium-holder coffee farmers in Karnataka, India. Farmers will be randomly assigned to (1) climate change salience information treatment, (2) probability training and climate change salience information treatment, (3) control.
Each farmer will answer survey questions, watch their assigned video(s), and play a hypothetical decision-making game where decisions depend on weather realizations and decisions are made after receiving a weather forecast. The game consists of two rounds. In the first round, farmers will receive hypothetical scenarios in which they choose between two locations with different weather forecasts, picking the location where a weather event is more (less) likely to occur. After their choice, a weather realization will occur in-game. Farmer payoffs depend on realized weather. In the second round, farmers will receive hypothetical agricultural scenarios, and choose whether to take an action or not, following a weather forecast. After their choice of action, a weather realization will occur in-game. Farmer payoffs depend on realized weather.
After the end of the game, we will elicit farmers’ willingness-to-pay for accurate, medium-range probabilistic weather forecasts.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.