Science versus Religion: Influencing Environmental Awareness in the World’s Fastest Sinking City
How to cite
Sim, Armand. 2023. "Science versus Religion: Influencing Environmental Awareness in the World’s Fastest Sinking City." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011525. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11525-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The primary objective of our study is to empirically examine the effectiveness of a video message addressing environmental concerns. The narratives in the video aim to motivate viewers to modify their behaviors and contribute to averting a significant environmental catastrophe. Our focus lies in evaluating the impact of two key factors: the content of the message and the person delivering it. We specifically intend to investigate how these factors influence public awareness, changes in beliefs and attitudes, and support for policies related to the potential submergence of a mega city in a developing nation. To achieve this, we will manipulate the content and presenter along two dimensions: religion and science. In terms of content, we will augment the standard environmental damage message with both religious and scientific narratives. Regarding the presenter, we will enlist the services of an actor who will portray two distinct roles: an academic/researcher and a Muslim religious leader or imam. To establish a baseline for comparison, we will also include a control group that will view a placebo video without a presenter. The study seeks to shed light on the most effective strategies for delivering environmental messages, thereby promoting public engagement and encouraging behavioral change among individuals.
Intervention
Evaluation of the effectiveness of different interventions that vary the content and presenter of a video message on environmental issues in the context of an impending environmental damage, severe land subsidence, in the Jakarta metropolitan area, Indonesia.
Experimental design
We will provide information in the form of a 3.5-minute video message presented by a presenter played by an actor.
We plan to have four treatment groups and a control arm. Each treatment group varies in two dimensions: the content and the presenter.
- Treatment group 1: Religious leader delivering a standard message about environmental issues in Jakarta + religious narrative
- Treatment group 2: Religious leader delivering a standard message about environmental issues in Jakarta + scientific narrative
- Treatment group 3: Scientist delivering a standard message about environmental issues in Jakarta + religious narrative
- Treatment group 4: Scientist delivering a standard message about environmental issues in Jakarta + scientific narrative
- Control group: Placebo video (unrelated to land subsidence issues in Jakarta; no actor appearance)
The sample consists of individuals aged 18+ residing in the Jakarta metropolitan area.
Our experimental design will compare outcomes among our sample individuals in the 4 treatment groups and those in the control group:
1) Compare the impacts of each treatment with the control group
2a) Compare the effectiveness of the presenter conditional on delivering the message with a religious narrative:
- the difference between T1 and T3
2b) Compare the effectiveness of the presenter conditional on delivering the message with a scientific narrative:
- the difference between T2 and T4
3a) Compare the effectiveness of the content conditional on the presenter being a religious leader:
- the difference between T1 and T2
3b) Compare the effectiveness of the content conditional on the presenter being a scientist:
- the difference between T3 and T4
4) Difference-in-difference between content (religious vs scientific narrative) and presenter (religious leader vs scientist): (T1-T2) - (T3-T4).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.