Testing the Impact of Subsidized Public Transit for Unemployed Persons

How to cite

Phillips, David. 2023. "Testing the Impact of Subsidized Public Transit for Unemployed Persons." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011522. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11522-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

David Phillips*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011522
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11522-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-05-25 – 2028-05-25
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11522

Abstract

There is substantial evidence to show that transportation poses a barrier for low-income individuals searching for jobs, especially for those residing in neighborhoods further away from job opportunities (Phillips, 2014). If an individual can’t pay for transportation to job interviews or training, job search intensity wanes and poverty persists.

Several researchers have studied the impact of free public transportation on people’s travel habits, finding that immediate transit use and mobility increase significantly. For example, one field experiment that provided free public transportation to a large group of employed individuals found a 12% increase in overall travel and a 23% increase in travel during off-peak hours (Bull et al., 2021). Another large-scale experiment that provided free transit to individuals with low income documented a doubling of transit use (Brough et al., 2022). These results show high potential for an uptake in transit usage and could suggest an even larger jump for a low-income population. However, a follow-up paper showed limited effects of the transit subsidy on hours worked (Brough et al., 2023). Null results for employment may have occurred because that study sample was too detached from the labor market or because free transit affects employment outcomes beyond hours worked and wage rates. The Wilson Sheehan Lab for Economic Opportunities (LEO) has partnered with the Seattle Department of Transportation (SDOT) and Uplift Northwest (Uplift), a temporary staffing agency serving a population of overwhelmingly low-income and/or homeless people, to bridge this gap by pairing free transit to people enrolled in Uplift’s job matching programs and studying its impact on employment and self-sufficiency outcomes using Uplift’s detailed data on participants’ interactions with the labor market.

LEO will be conducting a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to evaluate this program. Clients of Uplift who consent to participation will be randomly assigned to receive either a one-time $10 transit card or a fully subsidized transit card. Outcomes of interest include transit usage and labor market outcomes. We will also measure benefits utilization (such as SNAP and TANF) and housing stability.

Intervention

There is substantial evidence to show that transportation poses a barrier for low-income individuals searching for jobs, especially for those residing in neighborhoods further away from job opportunities (Phillips, 2014). If an individual can’t pay for transportation to job interviews or training, job search intensity wanes and poverty persists.

Several researchers have studied the impact of free public transportation on people’s travel habits, finding that immediate transit use and mobility increase significantly. For example, one field experiment that provided free public transportation to a large group of employed individuals found a 12% increase in overall travel and a 23% increase in travel during off-peak hours (Bull et al., 2021). Another large-scale experiment that provided free transit to individuals with low income documented a doubling of transit use (Brough et al., 2022). These results show high potential for an uptake in transit usage and could suggest an even larger jump for a low-income population. However, a follow-up paper showed limited effects of the transit subsidy on hours worked (Brough et al., 2023). Null results for employment may have occurred because that study sample was too detached from the labor market or because free transit affects employment outcomes beyond hours worked and wage rates. The Wilson Sheehan Lab for Economic Opportunities (LEO) has partnered with the Seattle Department of Transportation (SDOT) and Uplift Northwest (Uplift), a temporary staffing agency serving a population of overwhelmingly low-income and/or homeless people, to bridge this gap by pairing free transit to people enrolled in Uplift’s job matching programs and studying its impact on employment and self-sufficiency outcomes using Uplift’s detailed data on participants’ interactions with the labor market.

LEO will be conducting a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to evaluate this program. Clients of Uplift who consent to participation will be randomly assigned to receive either a one-time $10 transit card or a fully subsidized transit card. Outcomes of interest include transit usage and labor market outcomes. We will also measure benefits utilization (such as SNAP and TANF) and housing stability.

Experimental design

New clients visit Uplift Northwest’s offices in-person in order to complete their onboarding. During onboarding, clients will fill out a survey about their current transit behavior. As part of their onboarding, clients will meet with an SDOT intern, who will walk the client through the informed consent process for the research study. If the client consents to the study, they will fill out a digital intake form. At the end of the form, clients will automatically be randomized into either the control group, receiving an ORCA card preloaded with $10, or the treatment group, receiving a fully subsidized ORCA card that provides free transit for 12 months. Clients who do not consent to the study will also be provided with a one-time $10 ORCA card. All clients, regardless of consent or randomization status, will receive standard Uplift Northwest services.

Design details

Randomization method
The digital study intake form has an embedded randomizer which places the client in the treatment group with a probability of 1/2 or the control group with a probability of 1/2.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
The sample is not clustered.
Observations
832 individual Uplift Northwest clients
Arms
416 treatment, 416 control
Primary outcomes
Transportation: Number of boardings using study transit card Employment: Hours worked per week at jobs offered by Uplift Northwest
Secondary outcomes
Transportation: Number of boardings using study transit card Number of trips using study transit card Use of study card after subsidy expires Subsets of boardings by mode, line, time of day and location Employment: Hours worked per week at jobs offered by Uplift Northwest Hours worked per quarter at all UI-covered jobs Income earned from jobs offered by Uplift Northwest Total earnings Job characteristics Job performance Well-Being: Homeless Program Use Professional development opportunities utilized “points” accrued Receiving any public assistance Receipt of different types of assistance Expected overall cost of healthcare Indicator for any emergency department visit Indicator for any hospital inpatient visit Indicator for any outpatient visit Arrest within one year Whether individual moves Move location

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords