Construyendo hogares saludables: el efecto del mejoramiento de vivienda en el uso de prácticas que contribuyen a reducir y prevenir la violencia doméstica (Building healthy homes: the effect of housing improvements on the use of strategies to reduce and prevent domestic violence)
How to cite
Middelhoff, Charlotte; Diaz, Marcela Ibañez; Cantet, Natalia; Mora, Juan Carlos Muñoz; Amador, Tatiana Caly. 2023. "Construyendo hogares saludables: el efecto del mejoramiento de vivienda en el uso de prácticas que contribuyen a reducir y prevenir la violencia doméstica (Building healthy homes: the effect of housing improvements on the use of strategies to reduce and prevent domestic violence)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011504. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11504-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
About one third of families in Colombia live in insufficient houses with inadequate floors or no access to water in the kitchen (ECV, 2021) creating stress and tensions within the household. Moreover, there is a high prevalence of domestic violence with a high number of cases reported each year and around one in five children being exposed to corporal punishment (Cuartas et al., 2019). While inadequate housing is not the only reason behind domestic violence, housing improvements have been shown to improve overall household mental well-being (Curl et al., 2015; Devoto et al., 2012) and depression (Cattaneo et al., 2009) and to overall reduce stress, potentially, also decreasing domestic violence.
This project aims to measure the impact of the ‘Construyendo Hogares Saludables’ programme implemented by Cementos ARGOS consisting of training and subsidies for homeowners to make improvements of their houses. Conducting a randomized control trial with roughly 1200 households in 78 sections of the cities of Cali, Medellin, and Barranquilla, the study will analyse if better housing conditions will ease tensions and stress within households and, thus, reduce domestic violence. Additionally, the supporting effect of pledging to become a healthy, happy home on conflict resolution and, following, on stress and the prevalence on domestic violence will be evaluated.
Intervention
The survey includes two interventions. The first intervention involves a self-performed house improvement, while the second intervention consists of a promise (pledge) to follow family formulated household rules. Participants receiving the home-improvement intervention are considered to be in the treatment group, while those without are in the control group. Half of the treatment group will receive the pledge intervention.
Participants in the treatment group will take part in a baseline survey and, additionally, an assessment of their house will be conducted to determine necessary improvements and a corresponding budget. One household member can receive 40 hours of training on basic construction skills, both theoretical and practical. Afterwards, technical operators will deliver the required materials for the house improvements and will also monitor the improvements. At this point, participants in the control group will only participate in the baseline survey.
The pledge intervention will be given to half of the participants of the treatment group, after the house improvements have been finished. All members of a household will participate in this step. A short video will sensitize them on the norms of living together and their importance. Afterwards, they will discuss and agree on family strength to implement into their daily lives. At the end, all sign the pledge to become a happier and healthier home, which will be framed and handed over to them during a ceremony.
Eight months after the house improvements are finished and the pledge ceremony took place, all participants will complete the endline survey.
Experimental design
The study uses a clustered randomized control trial consisting of two treatment arms and a control group. We do a baseline and an endline survey.
To be eligible, participants must be living in houses with quality deficits that affect both physical and mental health of household members. Additionally, they need to live in a high socio-economic vulnerable neighbourhood, have little income themselves, and be low skilled.
The survey part of the study includes questions on how members of the household interact and respect each other, how often and how they argue, and if open communication is possible. Moreover, participants will be asked about the existence of family rules. To measure (female) empowerment, questions on the possibility to make one’s own decisions are added.
Treatments:
T0: Control group: Low-income families in control clusters with similar socioeconomic characteristics.
T1: House-Improvement: Beneficiaries of house improvement project receive an in-kind subsidy to improve floors, walls, kitchen or toilets. The subsidy includes materials and technical support on the project.
T2: House-Improvement + Pledge: Participants additionally receive information of the importance of family rules for peaceful coexistence at home. Families set individualized rules for the household and engage in a ceremony where they collectively pledge to follow the rules.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.