Determinants of gang entry
How to cite
Blattman, Christopher; Tobon, Santiago; Rodriguez-Uribe, Arantxa. 2023. "Determinants of gang entry." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011490. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11490-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In poor neighborhoods across Latin America, one of the largest social organizations is the street gang. They are often the largest employer in the neighborhood, especially of poor adolescent boys. It’s striking, then, how little we understand these firms and, most importantly, the decision-making process of young recruits. Medellin, Colombia, has hundreds of well-organized street gangs. We have partnered with the Secretariat of Education to conduct a population-based survey of two cohorts of grade 7 boys. We intend to conduct the surveys in roughly half of Medellin’s 200 public schools, and anticipate that roughly 10,000 boys will participate. In addition to measuring a variety of risk factors and preferences, the survey measures boys’ expectations of the pecuniary and non-pecuniary returns to various careers: low-skill, medium-skill, high-skill, and gang/criminal careers. It also assesses boys’ self-reported interest in each career and the career interests of their friends. Finally, the survey incorporates a series of information experiments to test whether it is possible to correct any misperceptions associated with gang entry. We used a first wave of roughly 1,200 surveys to identify likely misperceptions and pilot information experiments. These will be tested in the remaining to-be-surveyed sample. Experiment 1 targets the perceived returns to medium- and high- skill careers. Experiment 2 targets the perceived non-pecuniary returns to criminal/gang careers (status and enjoyability). We are interested in how these information treatments affect posterior beliefs, career interest in the gang, and interest in and take-up of information on non-criminal careers.
Note that this experimental design was updated in September 2023 to reflect the second information experiment launched in the same month.
Intervention
Experiment 1: Treated subjects receive information on expected earning potential among three groups: those who do not complete high school; those who complete high school; and those who complete tertiary education. Half of the treated subjects receive the information in the form of statistics and graphical figures. Half of the treated subjects receive the information in the form of a story about three friends who took different educational and career paths.
Experiment 2: Treated subjects watch a video featuring three actors who provide dialogue directly taken from interviews with current and former gang members. The selected dialogue emphasizes how they had high expectations of enjoyment and status from gang careers but how in the end status and enjoyability were low and friend, family and community relations were difficult.
Note that this experimental design was updated in September 2023 to reflect the second information experiment launched in the same month.
Experiment 3: (On hold). We originally envisioned a third experiment where treated subjects receive information designed to change beliefs about the probability of arrest, incarceration, and death in gang and criminal careers. This is on hold, in the event that the sample size of surveys can be expanded.
Experimental design
Experiment 1:
We expect treatment effects on our primary outcomes to be concentrated among high-risk pupils, and among pupils who underestimate the returns to high-school completion and higher education. We expect our primary outcome regression to take the following form:
Y = b1 T + b2 T*L + b3 T*E + b4 T*L*E + b5 L + b6 E + b7 X + S + e
where
Y is our primary outcome
T is assignment to the information treatment
L is an indicator for low risk (the number of friends interested in the gang career, using the same threshold as Y)
E is a measure of erroneous prior beliefs, centered at zero, where positive values imply overestimating returns to legal careers
X is a set of pre-information experiment control variables taken from survey and administrative data, selected using the double lasso method on primary outcomes
S is a set of school fixed effects
e is an error term (not clustered)
We expect b1 to be positive when the outcome is legal income, and negative when the outcome is gang interest. We also expect the effects to be larger for youth with priors that overestimate legal incomes, and so we are also interested in b3.
Experiment 2:
Experiment 2 began in September 2023 at the time of this update.
As with experiment 1, we expect treatment effects on our primary outcomes to be concentrated among high-risk pupils. In this case, also among pupils with high expectations of non-pecuniary returns to criminal/gang careers, such as status and enjoyability. We expect our primary outcome regression to take the following form:
Y = a1 T + a2 T*L + a3 T*E + a4 T*L*E + a5 L + a6 E + a7 X + S + e
where
Y is our primary outcome
T is assignment to the information treatment
L is an indicator for low risk (the number of friends interested in the gang career, using the same threshold as Y)
E is a measure of expected non-pecuniary returns to criminal/gang careers
X is a set of pre-information experiment control variables taken from survey and administrative data, selected using the double lasso method on primary outcomes
S is a set of school fixed effects
e is an error term (not clustered)
When Y is a measure of non-pecuniary benefits, we expect a1 to be negative. We also expect the effects to be larger for youth with priors that non-pecuniary benefits are high, and so we are also interested in a3.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.