Money or Network? Experimental Evidence on What Motivates Women to Enter Entrepreneurship

How to cite

Pape, Naja; Spina, Chiara. 2023. "Money or Network? Experimental Evidence on What Motivates Women to Enter Entrepreneurship." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011458. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11458-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Naja Pape* , Chiara Spina

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011458
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11458-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-06-06 – 2024-10-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11458

Abstract

Ample research documents the female founding gap, but we lack a thorough understanding of the reasons for this gap and of potential solutions to reduce it. We examine two main structural constraints that may prevent women from taking the first steps towards entrepreneurship: access to finance and access to a relevant network, and investigate to what extent these constraints play a role in the decision to enter entrepreneurship. We use a randomized recruitment campaign for an incubation program– a common first step towards entrepreneurship – to run a field experiment. Through the experiment, we test the impact of informational messaging treatments focused on getting access to finance vs. access to network on the decisions of women to apply for the program and complete it. In addition, we examine if this variation in messages results in different types of women applying for and completing the program. We expect findings from the experiment to uncover mechanisms that help explain the existence of a female founding gap at the entry stage and suggest remedies to it. A deeper understanding of the drivers behind the low rates of entry of female founders into entrepreneurship is not only important from a scholarly perspective, but it also has critical implications for policies and programs promoting entrepreneurship and the participation of historically underrepresented groups.

Intervention

We partnered with a well-established incubation center that has been a part of the Pakistani entrepreneurial ecosystem for the past five years and that is currently about to start inducting its 11th cohort of startups. We created a new incubation program and advertised it online through a ‘closed campaign’ – i.e., available only to a random subsample of the eligible population active on social media. To understand the importance of different types of structural constraints (i.e., either financing or networking, or a combination of the two) faced by potential female applicants, our intervention randomly varies the recruitment message emphasizing different benefits of the program. We then track if participants exposed to a recruitment message express interest in the program and complete the application steps for the incubation program. The incubation program is open to participants aged 18 years and older and that have a business at a pre-revenue stage.

Experimental design

The incubation program will be advertised uniquely using Facebook and Instagram (both owned by Meta and the main social media platforms in Pakistan and the main outlets of our partner organization’s outreach).

The intervention will take place through (a) the Facebook/Instagram ad campaign that randomly assigns different messages to potential applicants and (b) on the incubation program’s landing page (the header of the website will repeat the message from the Facebook/Instagram advertisement).

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization will take place using the A/B/C/D/E/F testing made available by Meta for campaigns using Facebook and Instagram. This way of setting up a campaign allows the advertiser/the researcher full control over the exposure of the ads, i.e., that the same Facebook or Instagram user will always be exposed to the same message. To make sure the same number of participants is exposed to an ad across conditions, we will strictly set balanced budget/audience requirements.
Randomization unit
Individual applicant
Clusters
0
Observations
Minimum 13,012 clicks for women and men combined.
Arms
Minimum 1,084 clicks per condition for women and minimum 1,084 clicks per condition for men.
Primary outcomes
• “Number of unique clicks per message” • “Has applied” • “Number of unique impressions per message” • “Total number of clicks per message” • “Click-through rate per message” • “Time spent on landing page conditional on clicking on the ad”: first visit and total time spent (conditional on the person being able to come back to the page)
Secondary outcomes
• Pitch deck • Additional baseline survey • Phone interview • Mechanism test (this is described in more detail in the pre-analysis plan document) • Start of the training • Completion of the training • Performance during the training

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords