Self-confidence, entitlement, and the POUM Hypothesis: an experimental study

How to cite

Cunsolo, Alessandro. 2023. "Self-confidence, entitlement, and the POUM Hypothesis: an experimental study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011450. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11450-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alessandro Cunsolo*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011450
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11450-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-06-01 – 2023-09-28
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11450

Abstract

The prospect of upward mobility (POUM) hypothesis finds that individuals who are poorer than the average optimally choose to oppose redistribution policies because they expect to be richer in the future, assuming full rationality, a mobility process that is concave in expectations, redistribution policies that last for a sufficiently long period, and individuals not too risk-averse. This is defined as the POUM effect. However, full rationality, on which the POUM hypothesis is based, seems to fail empirically. This leaves open some questions about determinants of the POUM effect, concerning the effect of self-confidence and entitlement on redistribution preferences. I designed an experiment in which the mobility process is endogenously modified by individuals’ relative performances or luck, and it is characterized by the POUM effect or not based on performances or luck. It has a certain and uncertain part, with the uncertain part being dependent on the experiment’s outcomes. Individuals expressed their redistribution preferences three times. First, they expressed their redistribution preferences with no future mobility. Second, decisions were taken knowing that there was future mobility and estimating the unknown part of the mobility function through expectations of subjects’ relative performance or luck, introducing the self-confidence or optimism effect. Finally, subjects made choices knowing that there was future mobility and their actual mobility function, introducing the entitlement effect across treatments. Other determinants of redistribution preferences, such as risk aversion and individual characteristics, are controlled through a specific test and a questionnaire.

Intervention

There are two treatments, respectively called “Random treatment” and “Effort treatment”. The two treatments differ in how the transition matrix is modified during the experiment. The transition matrix is a table that summarizes the probability with which every participant reaches a given level of income given a starting level of income. In this experiment, it is endogenously modified by individuals’ performance or luck. In the “Random treatment”, the transition matrix is modified according to the results of a lottery in which all subjects participate, whilst in the “Effort treatment”, it is modified according to the results of an effort test.

Experimental design

The experiment uses a between-subjects design, in which participants, who are recruited online, are equally and randomly divided across the experimental sessions.
The experiment is divided into two parts. In both parts, I collect subjects’ preferences over redistribution. In the first part of the experiment, subjects choose redistribution rates with no future mobility. At this moment, they do not know that mobility is possible in the second part.
The second part allows future mobility according to the probabilities given by the transition matrix, which is modified by an uncertain value “p”, initially unknown. It is made clear to subjects how the value of “p” is determined before the beginning of the second part. In the second part of the experiment, redistribution choices are made twice: not knowing the real transition matrix that will be applied to their initial income (i.e., with the value “p” unknown), and knowing it. Then, choices in the second part are different as the self-confidence effect fades away when the true value of “p” becomes known.
Before redistribution rates are chosen in the second part, I collect individuals’ expectations regarding the results of the effort test or the lottery (depending on the treatment). These expectations will be used to determine self-confidence (in the “Effort treatment”) and optimism (in the “Random treatment”) measures. At the end of the experiment. a questionnaire is proposed to collect individual characteristics.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by a computer, using the sofware z-Tree.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
The treatment is not clustered.
Observations
192 students
Arms
96 students will be in the first treatment and 96 students will be in the second treatment.
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variable of interest in this experiment is the redistribution rates participants choose.
Secondary outcomes
Self-confidence and optimism measures, a risk-aversion measure, political and religious orientation, and previous and current school information.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords