Large Scale Pilot Test of low-cost soil tests to promote sustainable farming practices among smallholder farms in Indonesia
How to cite
Grimm, Michael; Luck, Nathalie; Sawhney, Udit. 2023. "Large Scale Pilot Test of low-cost soil tests to promote sustainable farming practices among smallholder farms in Indonesia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011448. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11448-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates the impact of providing soil nutrient management training and conducting on-the-field manual soil tests to encourage smallholder farmers to adopt a balanced fertilizer application behaviour and to increase the use of organic inputs. The intervention is implemented as a Randomized Controlled Trial, wherein information and training sessions on soil management practices are provided in a farmer group setting. Villages were randomized into three groups: (1) Control group, (2) T1: 1-day training and (3) T2: 2-day training. In T2 we additionally offered soil testing. This allows us to investigate whether soil testing can augment the effect of soil health management training. Following the in-person training, farmers in T1 and T2 further received access to a digital extension platform. This platform provides videos and tutorials on the material taught during the training. The study relies on dual-wave panel datasets (baseline and end-line survey). Given the local context of unbalanced application of chemical fertilizers, we are particularly interested in investigating whether exposure to training influences farmers’ fertilizer application behaviour. The research design also permits the exploration of potential changes in farm yields, farming profits/losses, and also farmers’ knowledge about nutrient management in response to training.
Intervention
The intervention consists of providing soil nutrient management training and conducting on-the-field manual soil tests to encourage smallholder farmers to adopt a balanced fertilizer application behaviour and to increase the use of organic inputs.
Experimental design
We applied a multi-stage sampling design to sample 1,104 respondents from 69 villages, i.e. 16 respondents per village. In the first stage, we dropped unsuitable villages from the village database for the three districts - Sleman, Kulon Progo and Bantul. In the second stage, we randomly sampled one sub-village from each of the remaining villages (sub-village, or Dusun in Bahasa, is an administrative subdivision of a village in Indonesia). A team of enumerators then visited each sub-village to obtain more detailed information on farmers’ cultivation focus and demography from the sub-village head and the farmer group head. Information sessions about digital agricultural resources of a duration of about 2 hours were then provided in all the sampled sub-villages.
In the third stage, we randomly sampled respondents among the attendants of the information session. The three sampling criteria for respondents were as follows: (1) access to smartphone ownership, (2) rice cultivation of at least one plot and (3) younger than 65 years (70 years in case of farmer group head). In some information sessions, there were fewer than 16 suitable respondents. In such cases, we asked the farmer group head to provide us with contact details of further farmers who did not attend the information session.
The treatment was randomized at the village level and consisted of training on sustainable farming methods and the use of manual soil tests. Our RCT design consists of three groups - (1) control group, (2) treatment group 1 and (3) treatment group 2. The treatment arms are exclusive, allowing us to evaluate the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of different extension intensities.
Treatment group 1 was offered a short training, similar in structure and length to a typical training from extension officers (around 1 day). The training consisted of topics including the importance of soil nutrient management, the role of organic matter in the physical structure of soil, use of leaf colour chart, the principles of LEISA (low-external input sustainable agriculture) and digital resources that can provide farmers additional information on sustainable farming practices. It also included a practical session on how to prepare organic inputs. The training was jointly designed with the Agricultural Faculty of Gadjah Mada University (UGM) and trainers from P4S. P4S are self-help agricultural and rural training groups that are owned and managed by farmers. They exist in most districts in Indonesia and receive financial resources from the local government.
Treatment group 2 was offered a two-day training. The first day comprised the same training that was also offered to farmers in treatment group 1, whereas the second day focused on soil testing. The soil tests used were manual soil tests from the Indonesian Soil Research Institute (ISRI). These soil tests, which have been extensively tested and validated, help in testing the level of Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium (NPK), Ph, and Organic Matter in the soil. The second day also focused on materials specifically designed to assist farmers’ decision-making after soil testing. This included training on how to use the online soil test calculator and how to complement the soil test results with the recommendations given during day 1 on sustainable soil fertility management. The farmers received IDR 50,000 (around 3.5 USD) for each day of training attendance to cover any transport costs and to compensate them for a part of potentially foregone earnings.
To avoid any biased nominations and biased answers during the interviews, none of the treatment groups were informed about the upcoming training before the survey was completed in that village. Based on our survey data, we observe that the share of respondents who attended info-sessions was similar across the two treatment groups and the control group (T2 – 58.96%, T1 – 58.42% and Control – 57.61%).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.