Addressing Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR) and Self-Medication Practice (SMP) in Developing Countries: a Field Experiment in Bangladesh

How to cite

Imran, Khalid; Wiesen, Daniel; Goette, Lorenz. 2023. "Addressing Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR) and Self-Medication Practice (SMP) in Developing Countries: a Field Experiment in Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011418. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11418-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Khalid Imran* , Daniel Wiesen , Lorenz Goette

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011418
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11418-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-09-21 – 2025-06-01
Countries
Bangladesh ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11418

Abstract

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is a slow-motion pandemic. Knowledge constraints and lack of awareness regarding the adverse health impact of antibiotics are prevalent in third-world countries. Ahmed (2019) shows that many cherry-picked drugs are ineffective in Bangladesh as an outcome of antimicrobial resistance. Village doctors (quacks) are the leading healthcare providers in rural areas who are also not aware of the adverse impact of antibiotics on the human body and are one of the primary sources of antibiotic consumption. Often, reaching out to government hospitals or registered doctors impose transportation costs, so individuals go to medicine shops to buy medicine without registered doctors' concern. Local pharmacy owners provoke customers to buy antibiotics and other unnecessary drugs, boosting their sales. People routinely purchase commonly prescribed antibiotics over the counter to facilitate a speedy recovery. Overall, knowledge constraints and lack of awareness regarding the adverse health impact of antibiotics among mass people is a huge issue in addressing the Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR) problem. In this study, We will introduce an innovative information intervention to fight this problem that will potentially restrict unnecessary antibiotic take-up among mass people by targeting their medication behavior in Bangladesh.

Intervention

Informational Intervention: The goal of this intervention is to increase the target population's awareness and comprehension about the use of antibiotics. It entails disseminating pertinent information about the appropriate use of antibiotics, the risks associated with their improper use, and the significance of adhering to recommended dosages and schedules.

Behavioural Nudge Intervention: This intervention will promote constructive changes in behavior related to antibiotic use by drawing on insights from behavioral science. We will provide boxes to keep all medications purchased without registered doctor's prescriptions. That means we will ask our respondents to put their self-purchased , quack prescribed medicines to the provided box. The box will work as physical reminder of the provided information regarding dangers of antimicrobial resistance.

Intervention with Financial Incentives: This intervention will make use of financial incentives to encourage prudent antibiotic usage. We will provide transportation costs to nearest government medical facilities to reduce frequent use unauthorized and informal medical practices.

Experimental design

We have collaborated with a Bangladeshi NGO named "EHHD Foundation". We will conduct our study on the member households of an ongoing program named "kemon achen" or "how are you?".
The "Kemon Achen" program is dedicated to improving the health and welfare of rural women. We a have access to the database of member households, which will be resource in our research. Our experiment will be conducted specifically with the participants of the "Kemon Achen" program located in two upazilas (sub-districts) within the Dinajpur district of Bangladesh.

In our randomized controlled study, our objective is to identify the most effective strategy to reduce the prevalence of self-medication and visits to unregistered physicians, commonly referred to as "village quacks." Our primary goal is to curtail the unnecessary consumption of medications, a trend intrinsically tied to these practices. To achieve this, we plan to inform our treatment participants about the adverse consequences of antibiotic misuse and explore different channels to emphasize and reinforce this message. Our subjects will be divided between control(T0) and treatment groups(T1,T2).

T0: Control
T1: Information+ box(physical reminder )
T2: Information+ financial incentive(transport cost to nearest govt hospital)

With the information intervention, we will investigate the effectiveness of visual nudges (physical reminders) as a supportive tactic to reduce needless antibiotic consumption. We will give one treatment group containers/box to store medicines purchased without a prescription from an authorized physician. Each time they go for the medicine box, this tactic serves to remind people of the possible risks involved with self-medication, which encourages better judgment. By distinguishing between prescription and over-the-counter medications, this tangible reminder would act as a nudge, subtly dragging them towards better health behavior.
We will also look at the incentive approach combined with information treatment to reduce antibiotic abuse. Despite the subsidies and nearly free treatments provided by government hospitals, we observe that financial limitations, particularly transportation costs, are a significant deterrent to seeking treatment from registered (MBBS) doctors. So we plan to provide transportation costs as financial incentives if member households visit government facilities. They will be reimbursed for their transportation cost once they show the ticket to government hospitals.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Due to the close proximity of member households in the study area, providing information treatment presents a high probability of spillover and contamination effects between treatment and control group, which rejects the individual household-level randomization technique. Cluster Randomization offers a potential solution to address spillover and contamination effects. However, power calculations reject Village-level clusters as a feasible approach, given the limited number of 37 villages with two treatment and one control wing. On the other hand, we have GPS coordinates of each household, which facilitates us to adopt grid-based clusters. We will create 800 / 1000 square meter grid on the map of study area. It will give us approximately 75 grids. First we will randomize our grids between treatment and control group. Around 25 grid will enter into control group, households under these grids will get no treatments. The rest 50 grids (approx) will get treatment. In treatment group, everyone will get information treatment. Then we will randomize households at individual level with visual nudge(box) and financial incentives. So, first we will randomize grids between treatment and control groups. After that we will randomize treatments at household level.
Clusters
Around 1 square kilometer grid areas on the map will be our clusters. Given the location of households, we assume that there will be around 75 clusterss. So, one third (around 25) grids will serve as controls, receiving no information, while the remaining 50 will be treatment clusters where all individuals receive information.
Observations
Approximately 800 observations (households) grouped into 75 clusters
Arms
There will be around 250 households in 25 (approx.) control clusters. The other around 50 treatment clusters ( "Information + Box" and "Information + Financial Incentive"), will have round 550 households. Overall, there will be around 800 households.
Primary outcomes
Frequency of Government Hospital Visits Incidence of Self-Purchased Medication Antibiotic Consumption Visits to Non-Registered Physicians (quacks) Knowledge of Antimicrobial resistance Trust in Government Medical Facilities vs. Non-Registered Providers
Secondary outcomes
Quality of Life Healthcare Expenditure Community Awareness Health Literacy Behavioural Change
Sponsors
Name: CENTER FOR SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC BEHAVIOR , C-SEB Location: Germany Url: https://c-seb.de/
Partners
Name: Education, Health, and Human Development Foundation (EHHD Foundation), Bangladesh Partner_type: government Url: https://ehhd.org.bd/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords