Attribution of Failure and Success in Strategic Settings

How to cite

Lozano, Lina; Negrini, Marcello. 2023. "Attribution of Failure and Success in Strategic Settings." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011372. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11372-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lina Lozano* , Marcello Negrini

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011372
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11372-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-05-09 – 2026-05-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91, D90, D91, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11372

Abstract

During our educational and professional lives, we face failures and successes that we need to justify to ourselves and others. In most cases, failure and success are the results of an unknown combination of both internal factors (i.e., own ability and exerted effort) and external factors that are outside one own’s control (i.e., others or luck). The evidence suggests that when people attribute the causes of failure and success they often exhibit a “self-attribution bias” -attribute success to their own merit and failure to external sources- to maintain self-esteem. In this project, we study an additional reason for the self-attribution bias, a strategic one. We use an online experiment to test how individuals attribute noisy feedback when the source of the final outcome can be due to their own ability, someone else ability, or the computer's fault. In addition, following recent evidence on gender differences in attribution biases, we also test whether men and women use different failure and success justifications and study the consequences of it in a hiring context. Understanding the nature and economic consequences of gender differences in attribution of failures/successes is crucial, as it could be one of the causes of the observed gender gaps in the labor market such as the under-representation of women in top-level positions. Furthermore, following the recent literature on algorithm aversion, we also test whether people use different justifications when the source of the failure or success is due to another person versus when it is due to the computer, and study the perception of such justifications in a hiring context.

Intervention

During our educational and professional lives, we encounter both failures and successes that we need to justify to ourselves and others. In most cases, failure and success are the results of an unknown combination of both internal factors (i.e., our own ability and exerted effort) and external factors that are beyond our control (i.e., others or luck). In this study, we conducted an online experiment to test how individuals attribute noisy feedback to themselves and others when the source of the final outcome can be attributed to their own ability, someone else's ability, or a computer's fault.

Experimental design

Our experimental design consists of two experiments. We first conduct the worker experiment, where we measure the performance of the participants, labeled “workers”, in a general knowledge quiz and elicit their justifications of failure and success for their outcome in the quiz. In the employer experiment, we elicit the hiring behavior of participants, labeled “employers,” regarding the workers after observing how the workers justify the failure or success of their outcome in a knowledge quiz questionnaire.

For the worker, we use a 2x2 treatment between-subjects design. The first treatment variation consists of varying the source of the noise (i.e., the performance of the other matched player or the random number chosen by the computer). The second treatment variation consists in whether the justification message is displayed or not to the Employer and has payoff consequences for the Employer.

Design details

Randomization method
For the worker's experiment, Polific participants will be randomized to one of the three treatments by the randomization program in Qualtrics. For the employer's experiment, we will use a strategic method for incentivized hiring decisions. Prolific participants will be randomly matched with the workers from the worker's experiment by the computer.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
no clusters used
Observations
2600 prolific participants: 1500 workers, and 1100 employers.
Arms
Workers experiment: 1500 subjects (500 per treatment) Employers experiment: 500 subjects (250 per strategic worker's treatment) & 600 subjects (for the gender-revealed treatment)
Primary outcomes
Worker's self-attribution justifications conditional on whether is a failure or success, source of noise, gender, and individual beliefs about performance. Employer's hiring decisions based on the attribution messages sent by the workers conditional on the workers' treatment and the gender of the worker.
Secondary outcomes
At the end of the experiment, we elicit (i) demographics (gender, age, nationality, and education), (ii) worker's perception of lying behavior, risk, and social preferences, and the appropriateness associated with different justifications messages, (iii) worker's beliefs about the likelihood of being hired giving the message sent to the employer. We will engage in a heterogeneity analysis based on these characteristics.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords