Family Homelessness Prevention: A Randomized Control Trial

How to cite

Phillips, David; Bollman, Katie; Ahn, Seoyoon. 2023. "Family Homelessness Prevention: A Randomized Control Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011367. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11367-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

David Phillips* , Katie Bollman , Seoyoon Ahn

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011367
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11367-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-05-11 – 2028-05-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11367

Abstract

Mary’s Place is a nonprofit organization in Seattle that provides services to women and families with current and previous experience of homelessness with the goal of ensuring that no child sleeps outside. They are launching a new homelessness prevention service informed by Santa Clara County’s homelessness prevention program. Because the past policy focus has primarily been on treatment, there is little evidence about which prevention programs work best and for whom. Our research project attempts to address this gap in the research by comparing the efficacy and cost effectiveness of prevention as a whole as well as comparing two different prevention strategies within the sample population. First, when services are oversubscribed due to budget and staffing limits, Mary’s Place will use random assignment to determine who is served first. Comparing people higher and lower on the waitlist will measure the effectiveness of receiving assistance. Second, we will use a lottery among program participants to measure the effectiveness of (1) intensive homelessness prevention services with a large cap on financial assistance and access to repeat assistance relative to (2) a traditional model of a smaller-capped, one-time financial assistance. Thus, the primary difference between the services provided to the two groups will be the intensity of financial assistance.

The results of this study will be informative to policymakers and service providers in other communities that are interested in the most effective means of homelessness prevention. Enrollment began in May of 2023 and will continue until we have enrolled approximately 3,708 households. Researchers had not received data on outcomes at the time of filing of this pre-analysis plan. Given the potentially wide-ranging effect of homelessness prevention, we identified three outcome domains for study: (a) receipt of services, (b) housing stability, and (c) family and child well-being.

Intervention

Mary’s Place is launching a new homelessness prevention service informed by Santa Clara County’s homelessness prevention program evaluated in a previous LEO study. In this evaluation, LEO and Mary’s Place plan to study whether providing families intensive homelessness prevention services with no cap on financial assistance results in different outcomes compared to a traditional model of capped, one-time financial assistance.

Experimental design

This study will have a two-staged random assignment. First, eligible applicants will be randomly assigned to receive or not receive assistance. Second, people selected for assistance will be randomly assigned to receive one-time or intensive assistance. We will conduct two sets of analysis. . First, we will measure treatment effects of receiving any assistance across program pathways, we will use data from all applicants who enter the waitlist who were deemed eligible at the time of random assignment. Second, we will measure the relative effectiveness of the two treatment pathways. The sample for comparisons between treatment pathways will be restricted to those applicants who are selected from the waitlist, determined to be eligible, and establish an appointment with a prevention specialist. When analyzing outcomes external to Mary’s Place, we will also limit the sample to those who provide consent for us to obtain and use their external data.

Design details

Randomization method
There will be two stages of randomization which are done using the Mary’s Place internal database Agency. The first stage will take place online in the services application form on the Mary’s Place website. Those identified as having worked with Mary’s Place in the past or having been referred will be added to a waitlist for the one-time or the intensive prevention services group. Every week, Mary’s Place will randomly select part of each group to be assessed for eligibility.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
3708 households
Observations
3708 households
Arms
Approximately 1236 households will be assigned to the waitlist for intensive homelessness prevention services and 2472 households to the waitlist for the traditional model of a smaller-capped, one-time financial assistance. After three years of enrollment, we anticipate that we will have about 1,350 households served with one-third receiving intensive prevention services and two-thirds receiving one-time assistance.
Primary outcomes
Housing stability
Secondary outcomes
Exposure to violence: Any 911 call at their address related to domestic violence or any Medicaid claim for healthcare to treat injuries from violence Child welfare: Any record of contact with child protective services or foster care Evictions: Eviction filing, eviction judgment against Use or request of homeless services from other agencies: Enrolling in Emergency Shelter, Street Outreach, Permanent Supportive Housing, Rapid Re-Housing, Transitional Housing, or Diversion; Completing Coordinated Entry assessment Housing changes: Address changes, new address starts, existing address ends, neighborhood characteristics for most recent address Employment: hours worked, total earnings, employed Receipt of benefits: receipt of cash benefits; receipt of food benefits Credit: credit score, total debt balance, delinquency, total inquiries Healthcare use: total healthcare visits; visits by type (inpatient, outpatient, emergency); mental health treatment; mental health prescription fills Overall criminal justice system contact: any arrest; number of arrests; arrests by class and type of charge Schooling outcomes: attendance, disciplinary outcomes, and test scores

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords