Graduated Tax Rate Information and Tax Policy Perceptions and Preferences
How to cite
Sullivan, Patrick. 2023. "Graduated Tax Rate Information and Tax Policy Perceptions and Preferences." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011366. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11366-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Previous literature and public opinion polling have indicated that a sizeable proportion of the American public misunderstands the graduated nature of the U.S. federal income tax. How these (mis)understandings affect perceptions and preferences of the federal income tax system are less well understood. I start by investigating the predictors of graduated tax rate understanding. Then, after randomly assigning a sample of U.S. respondents to an informational video highlighting the key workings of the federal income tax’s graduated tax rate structure, I estimate the effects of providing this information on an array of tax-related perceptions and preferences. Finally, I add an additional level of randomization which provides a common political claim about tax brackets to half of the respondents. I then estimate the effect of receiving accurate, political claims, and a combination of this information on attitudes towards the introduction of a new tax bracket that would affect only the highest of income earners.
Intervention
To examine the impact of providing information about the graduated nature of the US federal income tax on tax policy perceptions and preferences, I implement a randomized survey experiment. The survey itself features two levels of randomization. Subjects will either be allocated to both treatment groups, a treatment and then control group, a placebo and then treatment group, or a placebo and then control group. This is further explained in the Experimental Design subsection below.
Experimental design
The experiment ultimately takes on a 2x2 factoral design
For the first level of randomization, respondents will be randomly allocated to either a treatment or placebo group using Qualtrics’ randomization tool. The placebo group receives a video that restates a prior knowledge question, with a simplified visualization of income portions and tax brackets. The treatment group receives a video providing a detailed answer to the prior knowledge question, a simplified visualization of income ranges and tax brackets, and a clarification of the key differences between marginal and average tax rates.
Respondents are then asked most of the questions related to the Primary Outcomes (End Points) listed above.
For the second level of randomization, respondents are again allocated to either a treatment or control group and asked about their opinions on the introduction of a new, greatly increased federal income tax bracket. The control group is asked about attitudes towards this policy directly, while the treatment group receives a claim used by some opponents to the policy.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.