"Unearthing the Treasure: Assessing the Impact of the Financial, Fiscal and Civic Education Program in Brazilian Public Schools"

How to cite

Meloni, Luis Eduardo Negrão; Madeira, Ricardo; Serson, Renata. 2023. ""Unearthing the Treasure: Assessing the Impact of the Financial, Fiscal and Civic Education Program in Brazilian Public Schools"." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011363. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11363-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Luis Eduardo Negrão Meloni* , Ricardo Madeira , Renata Serson

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011363
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11363-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-04-10 – 2023-10-31
Countries
Brazil (Distrito Federal)
JEL codes
H30
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11363

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of the Program "Em Busca do Tesouro" in promoting financial, fiscal, and civic education in elementary schools in the Federal District, Brazil. Developed by the National Treasury Team in partnership with the Maurício de Souza Institute, the program presents concepts related to financial decisions, public administration, and the relationship between the civic population and the government through comics with popular characters from Turma da Mônica (a famous national cartoon created by Maurício de Souza). The program is aimed at 4th and 5th-grade students, and its pilot is being conducted in a selected group of schools, in which students in the target age group will be exposed to program materials and involved in classroom activities. After the intervention, students will answer a questionnaire to assess the impact on their knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors related to fiscal, financial, and civic education. Expected results include increased students' understanding of the concepts covered. possible changes in their attitudes and habits regarding savings and other financial issues, a higher understanding and appreciation of public goods, and more active behavior regarding authority's accountability.

Intervention

The "Em Busca do Tesouro" program is an initiative designed to educate 4th and 5th-grade students in Brazil about financial, tax, and civic concepts through comic books from "Turma da Monica", a famous and traditional Brazilian cartoon by the "Instituto Mauricio de Souza".

This program is planned to span over eight weeks, not including the initial material distribution phase and an additional three weeks dedicated to teachers' training.

Each comic book story integrates elements from the four major areas in the Brazilian national curriculum for these grades: linguistics, mathematics, natural sciences, and human sciences. The objective is that students interact with the content in a cross-disciplinary and comprehensive manner, thereby enhancing the learning experience.

The program's pilot takes place during the first semester of 2023 in a randomized set of schools in Distrito Federal, Brazil. The schools had six weeks to enroll in the program. After that period, schools were paired according to relevant characteristics and randomized between treatment and control groups.

Experimental design

The Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) structure ensures the comparison between schools from the treatment group - those that have received the EBT Program - with schools from the control group - those that have not been treated in any way.

Initially, 113 schools enrolled to receive the program. Seven of these schools were not considered because there was not enough administrative data available to properly pair them. One school was a private institution and would not be comparable to the others, so it was excluded from the sample. The remaining 106 schools were paired using Propensity Score Matching (PSM) that considered their size, student performance, and infrastructure characteristics of schools.

The randomization process resulted in 53 schools in each group, totaling a sample of close to 18,000 students. Teachers in the treatment group underwent a three-week training period in which they were encouraged to watch training videos and study the instructor manual. They then were able to implement the suggested activities. Students in the treatment group went through an eight-week intervention during which they were exposed to lessons on fiscal, financial, and civic education. Two monitoring surveys were sent to teachers during the eight-week program period. In the latter survey, teachers were also asked impact questions.

After the 11-week period, data is collected from students through an in-person questionnaire.

The outcomes will be calculated, and data will be analyzed using the RCT methodology.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in an office with a computer, using the software R and the Propensity Score Matching (PSM) and Mahalanobis Distance methodology, in which school size and infrastructure, and student performance were taken into account. The randomization is recorded and can be reviewed upon request.
Randomization unit
The cluster unit for randomization is schools.
Clusters
106 schools
Observations
Approximately 16.400 students
Arms
53 schools control, 53 schools treatment
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are the enlargement of students’ vocabulary and the development of skills, abilities, and attitudes related to financial, fiscal, and civic education (their recognition of the value of money, the budget constraints, the importance of establishing priorities in consumption, the importance of saving and financial planning for maintaining their family’s quality of life and the government’s budget balance, the importance of prudent use of public and private resources, their role in exercising democracy, the social function of taxes and the importance of transparency and accountability).
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes are students’ interest in school and their assessment of whether the classes are dealing with their specific difficulties, students’ discussion about the themes of the activities with their parents, students’ beliefs about the capacity of the school to create a stimulating environment and to teach useful subjects to their daily life, students’ gains in basic math, impact on parents/family members and impact on children’s future self. Also, through the teachers’ survey, outcomes related to the monitoring of the program and assessment of the impacts on teachers’ skills, abilities, and attitudes related to financial, fiscal, and civic education will also be measured.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords