Building Strong Foundations: Large-Scale Early Childhood Human Capital Formation in Nepal

How to cite

Prakash, Nishith; Lacey, Lindsey; Saraswat, Deepak; Fiala, Nathan; Cohen, Rachel; Sabarwal, Shwetlena; Mishra, Mridul. 2023. "Building Strong Foundations: Large-Scale Early Childhood Human Capital Formation in Nepal." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011318. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11318-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nishith Prakash* , Lindsey Lacey , Deepak Saraswat , Nathan Fiala , Rachel Cohen , Shwetlena Sabarwal , Mridul Mishra

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011318
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11318-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-06-01 – 2023-03-03
Countries
Nepal ()
JEL codes
C93, J13, J24, I21, I25, H11
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11318

Abstract

Early Childhood is a crucial phase in the development of a child. Approximately 200 million children under the age of five years in developing nations have development deficits (Engle et al. 2007). Doepke et al. (2019) argues that these development deficits may pass on to the next generation, creating a vicious poverty trap. These early deficits may take the form of stunting or malnutrition, as well as the form of lags in cognitive and non-cognitive behaviors. Since early interaction with parents and teachers are important determinants of cognitive and socio-emotional aspects of children (Shonkoff et al. 2000), it is important that we study the knowledge and skill levels of parent and teachers in the developing economies to improve the nature of interaction between children and their surroundings.

This study is motivated by the idea that yawning gaps remain in the information levels of Early Childhood Development (henceforth, ECD) teachers, and parents, in the developing countries, on the importance of early childhood, especially in the marginalized communities. We intervene at two levels. First, we train the teacher in the ECD classroom on the best practices of early childhood in the treatment arm. Second, we provide an information nudge on these best practices to the primary caregivers of our sample students in the treatment group. By primary caregiver, we mean the parent or guardian who spends the most time with the child in our sample. As part of our intervention, we successfully conduct twenty sessions for caregivers of kids in our sample over a period of six months. These sessions are led by the trained professionals (either teachers or facilitators) covering a range of topics in early childhood development including stimulation, hygiene, nutrition, disability, etc., and were designed by Seto Gurans, a pioneer non-governmental organization working in early childhood development in Nepal. We also vary the treatment by supplementing the trained teacher with contract licensing of trained helpers, in-classroom and out-classroom.

Our study is based in fifteen municipalities in Jhapa district of Nepal. We carried out randomization at the school level, and mapped teachers from these schools to their respective ECD sections’ kids. These kids form the sample points for our study. We have a total of 201 schools in this study with 150 belonging to the treatment, and 51 to the control.

Intervention

Early Childhood is a crucial phase in the development of a child. Approximately 200 million children under the age of five years in developing nations have development deficits (Engle et al. 2007). Doepke et al. (2019) argue that these development deficits may pass on to the next generation, creating a vicious poverty trap. These early deficits may take the form of stunting or malnutrition, as well as the form of lags in cognitive and non-cognitive behaviors. Since early interaction with parents and teachers are an important determinant of cognitive and socio-emotional aspects of children (Shonkoff et al. 2000), it is important that we study the knowledge and skill levels of parent and teachers in developing economies to improve the nature of the interaction between children and their surroundings.

This study is motivated by the idea that yawning gaps remain in the information levels of Early Childhood Development (henceforth, ECD) teachers, and parents, in developing countries, on the importance of early childhood, especially in marginalized communities. We intervene at two levels. First, we train the teacher in the ECD classroom on the best practices of early childhood in the treatment arm. Second, we provide an information nudge on these best practices to the primary caregivers of our sample students in the treatment group. By primary caregiver, we mean the parent or guardian who spends the most time with the child in our sample. As part of our intervention, we successfully conduct twenty sessions for caregivers of kids in our sample over a period of six months. These sessions are led by trained professionals (either teachers or facilitators) covering a range of topics in early childhood development including stimulation, hygiene, nutrition, disability, etc., and were designed by Seto Gurans, a pioneer non-governmental organization working in early childhood development in Nepal. We also vary the treatment by supplementing the trained teacher with contract licensing of trained helpers, in-classroom and out-classroom.

Our study is based on fifteen municipalities in the Jhapa district of Nepal. We carried out randomization at the school level and mapped teachers from these schools to their respective ECD sections’ kids. These kids form the sample points for our study. We have a total of 201 schools in this study with 150 belonging to the treatment and 51 to the control.

Experimental design

We randomize the study sample of 201 schools into the following four arms:

Training Only (T1): The 50 schools in this arm receive treatment in the form of a trained teacher. This teacher conducts 20 parental-educational sessions with the caregivers of kids from their respective schools over a period of six months. The teacher educates the caregivers on various facets and best practices of early childhood. These sessions cover a range of topics on health, hygiene, disability, stimulation, and understanding the needs and importance of early childhood.

Training plus Outside Classroom Helper (T2): The 50 schools in the arm receive a trained teacher plus an additional outside classroom helper (henceforth, facilitator). This arm differs from T1 in the sense that the facilitator, rather than the trained teacher, conducts the parental-educational sessions as part of the intervention. We hired the facilitator on a contractual basis and trained them on conducting the parents-education sessions on early childhood. These sessions are similar to those conducted in the treatment arm T1.

Training plus Inside Classroom Helper (T3): The 50 schools in this arm receive a trained teacher plus an additional inside classroom helper (henceforth, helper). The teacher is responsible for conducting the 20 parental-educational sessions with caregivers of kids from our sample. The helper helps the teacher efficiently carry out the day-to-day activities in the classroom. Like the facilitator, the helper is hired on contract for a period of seven months. The helpers assist our ECD teachers in managing and carrying out the class activities. These sessions are similar to those conducted in the treatment arm T1.

Control(T4): The 51 schools in this arm received nothing from the perspective of teacher-training or parental-educational sessions.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
school
Clusters
201 schools
Observations
3213 kids
Arms
50 schools teacher training, 50 schools teacher training plus an in-classroom helper, 50 schools with teacher training plus an outside-classroom helper, and 51 control schools.
Primary outcomes
(i) Ages and Stages Questionnaire scores of the children in our sample (ii) Caregivers (Parents) stress index (iii) Caregivers participation in the early stimulation and learning exercise with their children (Practice of early stimulation and learning (Index))
Secondary outcomes
(i) Quality of our ECD centers measured by (a) observation of teacher-student interaction at the endline, and (b) checklist of required facilities and infrastructure in these ECD classrooms. (ii) Caregivers attitude to child discipline (iii) Caregivers understanding of disability (iv) Caregivers’ intensity of stimulation activities with their children Based on the ASQ scores (primary outcome of our study), we shall also compare the fraction of kids scoring in the risk-range of the ASQ in the treatment and the control.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords