Recruitment, selection effects and external validity in clinical trials
How to cite
Unfried, Kerstin; Priebe, Jan; Mbavu, Cédric. 2023. "Recruitment, selection effects and external validity in clinical trials." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011276. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11276-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
There is a notable lack of knowledge on the external validity of clinical trials. The proposed study aims to fill this gap by providing insights into the magnitude and implications of selection effects into clinical trials. The objective of this study is to identify who participates in clinical trials with a particular focus on people’s socio-economic characteristics, abilities, personality traits, preferences, and behaviors by comparing the trial population to a general population (adults age 18 to 65). We will elaborate on potential biases in the estimation of treatment effects. Additionally, using an RCT compromising a control and two treatment groups the study will investigate to what extent the information provided in the clinical trial recruitment process influences the participation in the clinical trial of various population groups. The control group receives a standard recruitment campaign. Intervention groups will additionally receive an intervention aimed at encouraging persons to participate, whereby intervention T1 will aim to activate altruistic concerns and motives among respondents by emphasizing the positive benefits of clinical trial participation for the society and others (emphasizing altruism) and T2 aims at fostering trust and highlighting the rights of clinical trial participants to reduce anxiety and misperceptions. The study takes place as part of the LoaLoa cinical trials conducted by researchers of CERMEL in Lambaréné, Gabon.
Intervention
After a baseline survey, households will be randomly selected into control or treatment groups. There is one control group and two treatment groups (T1 & T2). The control group represents a standard outreach activity as typically implemented by the staff of the research institute CERMEL in order to recruit participants for their clinical trials. The treatment groups comprise alternative elements: T1 will focus on activating altruism related concerns in respondents by emphasizing the importance of diagnostic testing and clinical trials for society. T2 will address possible mistrust and anxiety. In T2 the intervention will strengthen trust and inform respondents about the rights of clinical trial participants. All three recruitment campaigns are expected to take around 10 minutes and will be done by CERMEL staff.
Experimental design
The experimental design involves an RCT in which randomization occurs at the household-level. The RCT involves one control condition and two additional treatment arms (T1, T2). The RCT will involve four stages: Stage 1: the baseline survey, stage 2: the interventions, stage 3: a post-intervention questionnaire and stage 4: Various real-world outcome measures spaced over time.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.