Boosts and Nudges under GARP

How to cite

Denant-Boemont, Laurent. 2023. "Boosts and Nudges under GARP." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011269. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11269-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Laurent Denant-Boemont*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011269
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11269-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-05-22 – 2023-06-28
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91 ; D12 ; D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11269

Abstract

The aim of the study is to assess the influence of nudges and boosts on individual choice rationality in a risky context based on a laboratory economic experiment. In a between-subject induced budget experiment, participants make repeated allocation choices under different conditions. The choices are displayed graphically as dots on a budget constraint. This allows us to analyse variations in participants' economic rationality. We apply the GARP (Generalized Axiom of Revealed Preference) test to assess whether participants strictly abide by the utility maximization framework, and also evaluate their proximity with GARP by computing a rationality score (the Money-Pump Index). We design a total of 6 treatments : 2 nudge treatments, 2 boost treatment and 2 control treatments. In the control treatments, participants did not receive any help to improve their individual rationality. In the nudge treatments, they obtain some help directly within the graphical interface : the area where the choices are compatible with GARP is either directly identified visually, or implicitely selected through a default option. In the boosts treatments, before the series of allocation decisions, participants complete different tasks in order to improve their understanding of GARP principles. We also control for several socio-demographic characteristics including cognitive abilities, personality traits, fatigue, etc.
Whether or not it is possible to improve economic rationality at the individual level, and how, is indeed currently under researched, especially in an entirely non-parametric framework.

Intervention

In this research, we aim at assessing how decision support tools might improve economic decision-making. More precisely, we want to compare the impact of nudges and boosts on individuals’ deviations from utility maximization. Nudges had been considered since Thaler and Sunstein 2008’s book as cost-effective mechanisms to reduce the consequence of decision biases for individuals. More recently, some debate had risen about the persistence of nudges’ effects over time (Brandon et al 2022, DellaVigna and Linos 2022). Some authors have suggested that boost interventions (Hertwig and Grune-Yanoof 2017 ; Caballero and Ploner 2022, Banerjee and John 2020), -- ie, processes where elements of reflection and understanding for the mechanism are acquired by participants for « boosting » competence – might be more efficient and more persistent.
Our intervention consists in a laboratory economic experiment where participants make repeated allocation choices along a budget line using the induced budget experiment from Choi et al (2007a, 2007b). This method is based on testing the consistency of successive consumption choices by an individual with GARP (Generalized Axioms of Revealed Preferences). These allocation choices are incentivized and participants get a monetary payoff at the end of the experimental session that depends upon their personal choices during this task.
These participants are randomized into 6 experimental treatments (described below) : 2 control treatments, 2 nudge treatments and 2 boosts treatments. Each experimental session is divided in 8 steps for an expected duration of 1h45mn.

Experimental design

In our laboratory economic experiment, the main stage participants make repeated allocation choices along a budget line using the induced budget experiment from Choi et al (2007a, 2007b). This method is based on the consistency of successive bundle consumption choices by an individual to GARP (Generalized Axioms of Revealed Preferences). These allocation choices are incentivized and participants get a monetary payoff at the end of the experimental session that depends upon their personal choices during this task. This method is based on testing the consistency of successive consumption choices by an individual with GARP (Generalized Axioms of Revealed Preferences). These allocation choices are incentivized and participants get a monetary payoff at the end of the experimental session that depends upon their personal choices during this task.
These participants are randomized into 6 experimental treatments (described below) : 2 control treatments, 2 nudge treatments and 2 boosts treatments. Each experimental session is divided in 8 steps for an expected duration of 1h45mn.
In the control treatments, partcipants did not receive any help during the GARP sequence (nudges) or before the GARP sequence (boosts)
In our nudge treatments, participants get some help by the computer during each round. The computer uses previous choices made by each participant to indicate where the consistent-choices set lies for the current round.
In our boost treatments participants have the opportunity to learn during a 30' sequence about GARP principles and its implementation.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is made within the experimental platform: Participants register for particular time slots for which they are available and treatments are randomized at the session level. Participants can only participate once to the experiment, which is ensured by the experimental platform registration system based on ORSEE (See Greiner 2017).
Randomization unit
Session-level randomization: Participants register to participate on time slots and they are randomized in our various treatments. Individuals are randomly assigned to the treatment and comparison groups.
Clusters
385 participants for individual choices, with 70 participants for all treatments but control 2 (robustness check) for which we plan to recruit only 35 participants. Given a even split of participants within the experimental sessions, the number of experimental sessions to complete is 17.
Observations
385 participants will make 50 allocation choices. Moreover they will answer to 2 fatigue questionnaires (2 scores per participant, before and after the boost sequence). We also observe their answers during the boost sequence. Last, they should complete the Big5 personality test and the Cognitive Reflection Test before the usual post experimental questionnaire.
Arms
- in Control 1 (Basic 50-decisions sequence based on Choi et al 2007) we will have 70 subjects and therefore 70 independent observations - in Control 2, 35 participants - In Nudge 1: 70 participants - In Nudge 2: 70 participants - In Boost 1 : 70 participants - In Boost 2 : 70 participants
Primary outcomes
1) percentage of GARP-consistent participants 2) money-pump index.
Sponsors
Name: ANR NEWTS Location: France Url: https://anr.fr/Project-ANR-18-WTW7-0002

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords