The Demand For Self Image and Social Image

How to cite

Fiorin, Stefano; Rao, Gautam; Kanz, Martin; Ferman, Bruno; Bursztyn, Leonardo. 2016. "The Demand For Self Image and Social Image." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001124. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1124-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Stefano Fiorin* , Gautam Rao , Martin Kanz , Bruno Ferman , Leonardo Bursztyn

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001124
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1124-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-07-20 – 2016-08-31
Countries
Indonesia ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1124

Abstract

Consumers might choose to purchase certain products to show to others their own economic achievements and thus gain social status. Purchasing an exclusive product may also shape one' view of oneself, regardless of the opinion of others. We consider premium credit cards, which can be demanded not only for the services and benefits that they provide, but also for social image and self-image motives. Since qualification requirements for these cards are usually high, this is a financial product generally available only to wealthy individuals. This exclusivity makes it a well-know symbol of success, which might enhance the owner's social image and self-image. We design a phone marketing experiment to disentangle the roles of self- versus social image considerations as well as instrumental benefits in explaining the demand for a platinum card. Random variation in prices allow to us to measure customers willingness to pay for social status and self image. The experiment will also inform us on the complementarity or substuitability of social image and self image.

Intervention

We design a phone marketing experiment in which we randomize the characteristics of the product being offered and the scripts used for the call.
First, some clients are offered to replace their non-premium card by a premium card, while others are offered all of the extra services of a premium card on their existing non-premium card. Customers will thus be offered the same instrumental services: the only thing differing is whether the services are included in their present relatively nondescript card, or on the premium platinum card which might have an additional "status" component. If the share accepting the premium card is higher than the share accepting the added benefits to the non-premium card, we will have established that customers value the status associated with the exclusive premium card.
Second, we will randomize the exclusivity of this premium card: in the premium arm, half of the customers will be offered a platinum top 5 card (reserved to less than 5% of the customers), and half will be offered a platinum top 20 card (reserved to less than 20% of the customers). If the share accepting the top 5 card is higher than the share accepting the top 20 card, we will establish that customers value the exclusivity of the product.
To further disentangle the nature of the demand for status -- social vs. self-image -- we proceed with additional treatments.
First, some clients will be told that they were selected on the basis of their merit, while others will be told that they were chosen on the basis of luck. Both of these statements are true, since customers receiving these offers are randomly selected among those who qualify for the offer. Second, some clients are told that the premium card will look the same as the card they own (so, only they will know it's a different product), while half will be told it will have a different look (so, everyone will know it's a different product). Consider the premium conspicuous card, which looks different from the non-premium card. The script mentioning merit should activate both social and self-image channels -- the opportunity to build self-image since the offer is an acknowledgment of the customer's financial success, and social image since the distinctive platinum card is well recognized by others as a marker of elite status. On the other hand, the luck script should activate only the social image aspect. Consider now the discrete premium card, which look the same as the non-premium card. The script mentioning merit should activate only the self-image channel. The script mentioning luck should not activate neither the self-image nor the social-image channels. Being able to activate separately self-image, social-image, and both together will allow us to understand the interactions in the demand for these attributes (complementarity or substituability).
Price variation will allow us to estimate willingness to pay for different attributes.

Experimental design

Customers will be randomized in one of 18 groups along 4 dimensions: type of card (non-premium, discrete premium, conspicuous premium), exclusivity (reserved to 5% or 20%, only for the premium card), selection criteria (luck or merit, only for the premium card), and price (50,000 or 200,000 Rp).

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was conducted using a computer random number generator.
Randomization unit
We randomized at the level of the individual customer.
Clusters
No clustering.
Observations
1400
Arms
[100] non-premium 50,000 [100] non-premium 200,000 [50] discrete premium, Top 5, Luck 50,000 [50] discrete premium, Top 5, Luck 200,000 [100] discrete premium, Top 5, Merit 50,000 [100] discrete premium, Top 5, Merit 200,000 [50] discrete premium, Top 20, Luck 50,000 [50] discrete premium, Top 20, Luck 200,000 [100] discrete premium, Top 20, Merit 50,000 [100] discrete premium, Top 20, Merit 200,000 [50] conspicuous premium, Top 5, Luck 50,000 [50] conspicuous premium, Top 5, Luck 200,000 [100] conspicuous premium, Top 5, Merit 50,000 [100] conspicuous premium, Top 5, Merit 200,000 [50] conspicuous premium, Top 20, Luck 50,000 [50] conspicuous premium, Top 20, Luck 200,000 [100] conspicuous premium, Top 20, Merit 50,000 [100] conspicuous premium, Top 20, Merit 200,000
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcome: offer take-up decision

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords