There is evidence that labor market outcomes correlate with individuals’ health. We contribute to the literature by asking whether individuals with particular health conditions face different odds in applying for job positions. We use field experiments (correspondence tests) to investigate whether employers’ decision to invite a job candidate for a first interview is affected by the candidate’s health conditions.
Experimental design
We send fictious CVs to job vacancies. We send 4 applications to job openings, composed of a CV and a motivation letter. We signal three types of health conditions and one control (the undisclosed health condition). Health conditions are signaled in both the CV and the motivation letter.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization
We send fictious CVs to job vacancies within the occupations considered. To each job offer, we send the three treatments and control. For each occupation, we create 4 versions of a CV and motivation letter corresponding to the three treatments and the control used. For the obese profile we have 26 different photo-applications, for which we randomly pick one. The randomization ensures that in the aggregate health conditions and gender of the applicants are fully balanced.
To avoid order effects associated with the treatments (the health conditions) we create a predefined sequence of applications to be sent to job vacancies. This sequence establishes that the order of applications of treatments and control sent varies across job vacancies (subjects). We send four applications to each job vacancy, sequentially in different days, but making sure all four applications are sent within 4-7 days. The randomization ensures that in the aggregate health signals and gender of the applicants are fully balanced.
3. Experimental design
The field experiment is to be conducted between June 2023-December 2024. During this period, job advertisements in selected occupations found on a few different employment search websites will be collected. A clear majority of employers posting vacant jobs at these sites want applications to be sent in by e-mail. This facilitates our experimental design of attaching photos to the job application, since it can be done electronically. Callbacks for a job interview will be received via telephone or e-mail. To minimize inconvenience to the employer, invitations will be promptly declined.
We have done a pilot of the experiment in a pilot of the experiment over April 2022-August 2022. Simple averages show difference in treatment across health conditions being women in wheelchair the least successful applicants. The objective is to increase precision of the estimates with more applications sent.
4. Deception
The correspondence testing methodology relies on the use of deception, a practice deemed acceptable by ethical review boards when the societal value of the research outweighs the potential costs associated with deception. The pursuit of equal opportunities for all citizens in the hiring process holds significant social value. Notably, the EU Code of Ethics for Socio-Economic Research supports the use of deception in correspondence testing studies on hiring discrimination (Dench, Iphofen and Huws, 2004, Zschirnt, 2019). However, these guidelines also emphasize the importance of minimizing the impact on employers undergoing the study. Adhering to these strict protocols, we have taken measures to reduce the time and effort required by employers to evaluate the additional job application. The deliberate use of minimal deception ensures that research subjects are not unduly harmed.
We must consider the consequences of sending fictious applications and subsequently declining an invitation in our specific experiment. We observe employers recruiting in their normal hiring situation, and we do not lure employers into a new and unfamiliar situation in which they are enticed to deviate from their normal behavior. We limit the burden on the employers’ time by considering an employer only once. Any invitations to interviews are quickly and politely declined in order to keep the extra effort to a minimum. By following these rules the loss of time should be considered minimal. Finally, data is anonymized and the results presented in aggregate form.
We believe that our intervention plays a minor role in the broader job market dynamics, and that deception does not harm subjects beyond what is usual in reality, or in a typical economic experiment without deception (see Appendix II for a note on deception).
5. Soundness of the randomization procedure
We send the applications as job vacancies are posted following the sequences pre-determined. Each recruiter faces the three treatments and the control 1. Therefore randomization is guaranteed by design.
Randomization unit
companies posting job offers.
Clusters
approximately 1759 companies posting job offers.
Observations
7036 cvs sent to 1759 companies.
Arms
1759, each firm is treated as a unit of experimentation exposed to the three treatments and the control.
Primary outcomes
Our primary end-point is the callback rate defined as the share of applications having received an invitation for a follow-up interview.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.