Acceptance and Impact of introducing sliding scale payment policy into CBHI in Ethiopia: Randomized controlled trial

How to cite

Koricha, Zewdie Birhanu; Deressa, Beshea; Abafita, Jemal; Abdulbari, Shabu; Abdissa, Bikiltu; Alzua, Maria; Sudhakar, Morankar; Cantet, Natalia. 2024. "Acceptance and Impact of introducing sliding scale payment policy into CBHI in Ethiopia: Randomized controlled trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011191. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11191-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zewdie Birhanu Koricha* , Beshea Deressa , Jemal Abafita , Shabu Abdulbari , Bikiltu Abdissa , Maria Alzua , Morankar Sudhakar , Natalia Cantet

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011191
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11191-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-11-01 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11191

Abstract

The Ethiopian government initiated a Community-Based Insurance scheme (CBHI) in 2011 to enhance financial protection for the informal sector. As of 2020, 8.4 million households were enrolled in the scheme. However, one of the CBHI's challenges is that households contribute an equal amount of premium (flat-rate contribution in majority of the settings across the country) regardless of their economic status and ability to pay. This adversely affected the lower-income households, sustainability, and equity of the program. To address this challenge, a new policy initiative, a sliding scale (SS-CBHI) contribution system based on households’ economic status is under consideration. This study is intended to evaluate the impact of introducing the new policy initiative using a Randomized controlled trial (RCT).The new policy initiative will be implemented in both rural and urban areas of these regions. Randomization will be conducted at the district level. A total of 5200 households will participate in the study. Households in the control areas will continue paying fixed rates whereas the households in the treatment areas will pay differential rates based on socio-economic status.

Intervention

Conditions in treatment arm: In the treatment arm of this study, all households within the district, referred to as clusters, have enrolled in a new policy initiative known as the sliding scale CBHI contribution scheme. This initiative bases its contributions on the economic status of households, regardless of age, gender, or family health risks. Under this scheme, households in the treatment district will pay an annual CBHI contribution rate determined by their economic level as stratified by the Ethiopian Health Insurance Service (EHIS). There will be different stratification for urban and rural residents.
Upon successful enrollment, each household will receive a health service coupon, or CBHI identification card, containing pictures of all insured household members. This card grants access to health services at designated health facilities, primarily health centers within their administrative units. Patients can also seek care at district/general hospitals or referral hospitals as per the referral chain within the system. The enrollment and ID card are valid for one year from the issue date and must be renewed annually using similar procedures to initial enrollment. The implementation of these interventions, including enrollment and health services, is overseen by the national EHIS, the Ministry of Health, and regional health bureaus such as the Oromia Regional State Health Bureau and Sidama Regional State Health Bureau.
Conditions in control arm: In contrast, communities in control districts remain under the current fixed-rate CBHI contribution scheme. Enrollment at the household level is independent of family health risks and socioeconomic status, with a fixed annual premium for all households regardless of economic standing. However, there are variations in rates for urban and rural residents. Additionally, 20% premium required for each household member aged 18 years and above. The government fully subsidizes the contribution for the poorest households, ensuring their access to healthcare services.

Experimental design

This impact evaluation will be based on a two-arm pairwise cluster randomized controlled trial involving one treatment arm and one control arm where assignment to the treatment will be randomized at the district level. Accordingly, 13 clusters (10 rural and 3 urban areas) is randomly assigned to treatment arm ( pilot for new policy initiative) and 13 ( 10 rural and 3 Urban areas) is assigned to the control arm, which means these districts will remain under existing CBHI premium scheme. Within cluster, the study population will be comprised of all households (irrespective of their economic status) in rural and urban clusters (districts) in selected districts of Ethiopia.

Design details

Randomization method
In this RCT, the district was used as a unit of randomization whereas households under each district will be used as a unit of observation (measurement) and the randomization was done in office by a computer software.
Randomization unit
The district is used as a unit of randomization whereas households under each district will be used as a unit of observation (measurement). Randomization at the district level is chosen for practical reasons: • We will randomize districts under each geographic (rural and urban) area by considering implementation and administrative feasibility. • Because of resource constraints, considering small clusters at the level below that (PHCU and kebele/villages) level yields very low power of the study (<15%), and practically it’s difficult to implement due to methodological challenges (contamination and spillover effects). • Methodological challenges (contamination and spillover effects). Randomization within geographic areas will help to reduce the imbalance/variation between regions, geographic areas, and district-level covariates.
Clusters
In this RCT, 26 clusters (districts/towns) are included:13 in treatment clusters and 13 in control clusters. Specifically, 18 comparable districts (7 pair-wise rural districts and 2 paire-wise Urban for the Oromia region, and 8 comparable districts- six rural districts and two Urban for the Sidama region was included the experiment.
Observations
There will be three survey rounds (baseline, mid-term, and end-line) observations. At each round, a total of 5200 households will be included, including all of their family members.
Arms
The sample is calculated using Stata 16.0 version. Using 1:1 allocation ratio, interclass correlation of (ICC=0.25) and 200 household samples per cluster, the 5200 total sample and 26 total clusters are required for the study. Therefore, we will recruit 200 households per cluster or pair (200 households x26 clusters =5200 households) for treatment and the same size of households in the control areas at each measurement points.
Primary outcomes
Three primary outcomes with separate indicators and measurements will be assessed for this experiment: 1. Financial protection which includes out-of-pocket health expenditure per capita; catastrophic health expenditure and Impoverishing spending 2. Health service utilization-outpatient and inpatient service utilization 3. Women empowerment for health service utilization explained in terms of gender disparity Equitable health service utilization and the reduced disparity between household economic statuses 1. Financial risk protections (out-of-pocket health expenditure per capita; catastrophic health expenditure and Impoverishing spending) 2. Indicators of women empowerment and gender equity in healthcare utilization 3. Acceptance (uptake, renewal, dropouts, rates) and beneficiaries’ satisfaction with the new policy initiative
Secondary outcomes
There are two crucial secondary outcomes: 1) Acceptance and satisfaction with the new policy initiative 2) Perceived quality of services and satisfactions with health services

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords