Effects of Quality Improvement Strategies on Early Child Development in Community-based Childcare Centers in Malawi: A Cluster-Randomized Trial
How to cite
Ozler, Berk; Fernald, Lia. 2016. "Effects of Quality Improvement Strategies on Early Child Development in Community-based Childcare Centers in Malawi: A Cluster-Randomized Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001118. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1118-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The majority of children who attend preschool in poor countries attend informal ones, which are often staffed by teachers with low levels of education and minimal formal training. We evaluate a government program in Malawi, which focused on improving quality at community-based childcare centers (CBCCs) and complemented these efforts with a group-based parenting support program. The study, which is a cluster-randomized controlled trial with four arms, covers 199 CBCCs in four districts of Malawi.
Intervention
The Protecting Early Childhood Development Project (PECD), co-designed by the Ministry, World Bank officials, and academic partners from UC Berkeley to ensure both technical, scientific, and policy relevance, was a two-year project aimed to mitigate some of the negative impacts of the global economic crisis on young children’s development by testing strategies to improve the quality and stability of existing CBCCs. The interventions focused on: (a) improving the play and learning resources in CBCCs; (b) strengthening the capacity of teachers to support children’s early development and learning; (c) teaching parents about how to support development and learning activities in the home. Under PECD, the Government implemented the following interventions – in partnership with Save the Children and UNICEF:
T1. Comparison Group: Provision of play and learning materials
To address the basic developmental and learning needs of children, each center in the study received a kit of basic play and learning materials and supplies procured by UNICEF. The contents of the kit were developed by the Ministry and included items such as books, displays, balls, paint, chalk, blocks, puzzles, first aid kit, and kitchen utensils. To participate in the project, CBCCs had to make space available for secure storage of the materials; all CBCCs that were selected chose to participate.
T2. T1 + Training and mentoring of teachers
To improve the knowledge, skills, and practices of teachers in the 150 CBCCs assigned to the three treatment groups, the project tested an enhanced teacher-training package. The teacher-training component followed a cascade model, where national ECD specialists trained regional trainers, who then trained the teachers at CBCCs within their regions, and aimed to build early childhood development (ECD) capacity at the national, district, and community levels. Each CBCC in a treatment group nominated two teachers to participate in the training program. Training candidates were required to hold a Junior Certificate of Education (JCE). If none of the active teachers at the CBCC met this minimum qualification, it was recommended that the CBCC seek and nominate an eligible volunteer from the same village. However, in practice, candidates with only a primary school leaving certificate (PSLC) were nominated by the centers and were accepted for training.
The teacher-training program consisted of five weeks of residential training divided into two sessions of two weeks each and one final one-week session. The enhanced training program built on and expanded the existing 14-day training that was available to all teachers and covered the following modules: child development; play and early learning materials and equipment; learning through play; planning and organizing the learning environment; child health and care; child hygiene and environmental care; child nutrition and care; child rights and their welfare; care and development of children with special needs; early childhood care, management, and partnership. Between the three face-to-face training sessions, the trained teachers went back to their CBCCs for a few months to participate in “field practice” with support from supervisors and mentors. During these field practice periods, the teachers in training held briefing meetings with the untrained teachers at the CBCC. 310 teachers from 150 treatment CBCCs (out of a total of 468 teachers at these CBCCs) completed all three phases of training.
Mentors and supervisors were trained for three days after the first face-to-face training session. Mentors were teachers selected based on their exceptional performance, reputation in the community, and commitment to their work. Mentors provided guidance and support to teachers in their respective districts through weekly visits. Each mentor was assigned to four CBCCs translating to a ratio of one mentor to eight teachers. Supervisors were Child Protection Workers, government-employed social workers, who already worked within the area of the CBCCs. These 19 experienced Child Protection Workers were each responsible for supervising eight CBCCs on average. National and district officials, along with Save the Children staff, also conducted monitoring visits. Finally, to strengthen the capacity of Center Management Committees (CMC) in carrying out their responsibilities to managing the centers, the project included a five-day training conducted within the communities, which reached 1,499 committee members from 150 CBCCs.
T3. T2 + Teacher incentives
In each of the 49 CBCCs assigned to this group, the teachers who successfully completed the teacher-training program were given a small monthly stipend (MK 2,000) for a period of seven months to increase retention and perhaps improve motivation. Unfortunately, the intervention period coincided with an economic crisis in Malawi, which saw the value of this payment depreciate from the equivalent of $12 to $6 per month from April to November 2012. Save the Children personnel administered the payments and ensured that the trained teachers received the incentives. In several communities, CMCs raised some funds to make comparable payments to the teachers who did not receive the enhanced teacher training.
T4. T2 + Parenting education
Primary caregivers of three and four year-old children attending the 51 CBCCs assigned to this arm participated in group sessions that provided information and demonstrated practical activities that they could replicate at home to maximize the school readiness of their children. Parent educators – Child Protection Workers, trained teachers, and mentors, who received three days of training for this task – facilitated the sessions. The initial implementation of the parenting education arm, organized by Save the Children, deviated from the original project design in that the 12 parenting sessions were first conducted in 12 consecutive days instead of 12 days spread out over six weeks. To rectify this implementation error, starting approximately one month later, the facilitators held six additional “refresher” sessions of two hours each over a period of six weeks. In between these weekly sessions, parents and guardians were encouraged to practice with their children at home what they had learned.
The sessions covered the following topics: introduction to child development; physical development, mathematical and critical thinking; general knowledge and scientific thinking; language development; literacy; social and emotional development; supporting spiritual and moral development; supporting children’s approaches to learning; supporting children’s health and safety; supporting children’s nutrition and food safety. Participants used items from the kits provided to the CBCCs by UNICEF along with locally available materials, such as leaves, stones, soil, feathers, bean bags, charcoal, drums, etc.
Experimental design
Cluster0randomized controlled trial with one control group and three treatment arms. A sample of 199 clusters (CBCCs) containing 2,120 boys and girls aged 36-60 months.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Ozler et al. (2018). "Combining Pre-School Teacher Training with Parenting Education: A Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial," Journal of Development Economics, Volume 133: 448-467. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304387818303808
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.