Empirical Tests of What Can Induce Households to Recycle
How to cite
Fullerton, Don. 2023. "Empirical Tests of What Can Induce Households to Recycle." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011141. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11141-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Household garbage causes environmental damage, and landfills run out of space, but recycling technology is improving for more materials to be sold by municipalities to help defray costs. Yet households do not directly benefit from recycling, so they often do not recycle. The goal of this research is to test whether there are cost-effective ways to reduce garbage and increase recycling. This pilot study will inform the study design of a larger study aimed at estimating the impacts of information interventions and incentives on quality and quantity of recycling and garbage at the household level. As part of the pilot study, we will also test alternative approaches to data collection.
Intervention
Household garbage causes environmental damage, and landfills run out of space, but recycling technology is improving for more materials to be sold by municipalities to help defray costs of waste disposal. Yet households do not directly benefit from recycling, so they often do not recycle. The goal of this research is to test whether there are cost-effective ways to reduce household garbage and increase their recycling. This pilot study will inform the design of a larger study. As part of this work, we are interested in testing approaches to data collection.
For this pilot study of 150 households in Rantoul, Illinois, starting with a 6-week baseline period, we will measure the weight of each 96-gallon garbage cart and recycling cart. We will open each cart – but not reach inside – to record the percent full, the number of non-recyclable items visible at the top of the recycling cart, and the number of recyclable items visible at the top of the garbage cart. Then we keep 50 households in a control group with no change and invite 50 households to earn $50 to join each of two treatment groups. One is a recycling “Information Treatment” group (where 50 households take two quizzes to ensure they read it). The other 50 are invited to a recycling “Incentive Treatment” group that includes the same information treatment plus financial incentives to recycle. The Incentive Treatment group will get the same $50 to take the same quizzes, and they will get paid $10 per proper recycling cart. Then we take quantity and quality measures again for all 150 households for another 8-week period. The changes in weight of garbage and recycling for each treatment group can be compared to the changes for the control group to estimate exactly the effects of each treatment.
We will not only record the visual measures for each cart but also send a picture of the top of each cart via the app provided by “Zabble Zero-Waste” (https://www.zabbleinc.com/). It employs artificial intelligence (A.I.) to observe and estimate the quantity (% full) and quality (number of wrong items visible) in each garbage and recycling cart.
After we have finished collecting these 14 weeks of measures for garbage and recycling quantity and quality, we will invite a randomly selected subset of individuals from each treatment group to participate in a focus group, so that we can ask for feedback about their experiences in the study.
In addition, we have purchased data from Data Axle that provides an estimate of the socioeconomic characteristics of each dwelling’s occupants. These data include basic demographic characteristics, such as the age of the head of the household, whether the head of household is married, a measure of the household’s income, political affiliation, and the number of children residing in the household.
Experimental design
For this pilot study of 150 households, we will measure the weight of each garbage can and recycling can for a 6-week baseline period and rate each household’s recycling quality by recording what garbage items in the recycling cart (and recyclable items in the garbage cart). Then we keep 50 households in a control group with no change and invite 50 to join a recycling “Information Treatment” group (and to take two quizzes to ensure they read the information). The remaining 50 are invited to a recycling “Incentive Treatment” group that includes both information and financial incentives to recycle. The Incentive Treatment group will be invited to take the same quizzes, and to get paid for proper recycling. Then we take quantity and quality measures again for all 150 households for another 8-week period. The changes in garbage and recycling for each treatment group can be compared to the changes for the control group to estimate exactly the effects of each treatment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.