Eliciting Social Norms
How to cite
MADIES, Pauline; Wang, Stephanie W; Huffman, David B. 2023. "Eliciting Social Norms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011132. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11132-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In the experimental literature, social norms are identified by using the method developed by Krupka and Weber (2013).
We plan to replicate the Krupka and Weber experimental design for eliciting social norms using coordination games with a simple modification to test whether this modification leads to similar or different elicited norms.
Intervention
In their seminal paper, Krupka and Weber (2013) develop an incentivized elicitation method for identifying social norms that uses simple coordination games. Participants are incentivized to match with the modal answer in their judgments.
In this study, we want to test whether the elicited social norms will be different if we ask one group to state the social appropriateness of various actions in different allocation games and another group to guess these social appropriateness ratings rather than asking the same group to complete these two tasks in one. Participants from the latter group will be incentivized to guess the social appropriateness rating most frequently given by participants in the former group. We will test whether this elicitation method leads to similar or different elicited norms than Krupka and Weber (2013).
We will also collect data on demographic attributes, social preferences and cognitive ability from our participants at the end of the experiment to test whether these characteristics are correlated with elicited social norms.
Experimental design
We use a between- subject design in an individual decision-making study. Each participant is randomly assigned to either an incentivized or an unincentivized session and is paid a participation fee of $7.
Each participant will first read the descriptions of a series of situations. These descriptions correspond to situations in which one person, "Individual A", must make an allocation decision. For each situation, participants will be given a description of the allocation decision faced by Individual A. This description will include several possible choices available to Individual A.
After they read the description of the decision, participants in the unincentivized sessions will report the social appropriateness of each possible allocation decision on a scale. Participants in these sessions will be asked to report their ratings as truthfully as possible, based on their opinions of what constitutes socially appropriate or socially inappropriate behavior.
In the incentivized sessions, participants will be asked to guess the rating most frequently given by participants in the unincentivized sessions. At the end of the session, we will randomly select one of the allocation situations. For this situation, we will also randomly select one of the possible choices that Individual A could make. Thus, we will select both a situation and one possible choice at random.
For the choice selected, participants will receive an additional $10 if their guess corresponds to the answer most frequently given by participants in the unincentivized sessions.
At the end of both types of sessions, participants will be asked to complete a post-experiment survey including questions on demographic characteristics, social preferences and cognitive ability.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.