Early Adopters, Peer Leaders and the Diffusion of Agroecological Knowledge

How to cite

Subervie, Julie; Deperrois, Rose; Fadhuile, Adélaïde; Thoyer, Sophie. 2023. "Early Adopters, Peer Leaders and the Diffusion of Agroecological Knowledge." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011129. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11129-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Julie Subervie* , Rose Deperrois , Adélaïde Fadhuile , Sophie Thoyer

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011129
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11129-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-11-24 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q15; Q18; Q25; Q28; Q53
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11129

Abstract

The diffusion of knowledge between peers is a subject of increasing attention in many areas of economics research. Influence from peers can indeed generate social multiplier effects, whereby an initial investment targeting one small group can lead to larger changes, since individuals close to the target group tend to imitate them and learn from their experience. When it comes to the green transition in agriculture, the diffusion of new knowledge through peers could play a crucial role in promoting the adoption of agroecological practices. However, the conditions for successful peer learning in this context are still poorly understood. In particular, it is unknown whether the profile of the first individuals in peer groups to receive information affects its diffusion to other peers, which includes the action of transmitting, the action of receiving and possibly also the action of catalyzing transfers and creating an emulation that makes the information more salient.

To answer this question, we run a randomized-controlled-trial (RCT) from a large sample of voluntary French farmers, where individuals are randomly assigned to peer groups and receive informative content for 18 months through a digital platform. Only one farmer per peer group receives the information directly in treated groups, serving as the injection point of the group. Treatment varies depending on the profile of the designated injection point, which is either chosen randomly among early adopters of agroecological practices (treatment arm A) or among ordinary peers (treatment arm B). We compare these two treatments to a benchmark group where we broadcast the information directly to all participants (treatment arm C).

Using this experimental design, we measure peer information sharing and test the hypothesis that receiving second-hand information can improve knowledge levels, as well as, and perhaps better than, receiving first-hand information. A major advantage of this protocol is that it can test the hypothesis that early adopters do better than ordinary peers, whether it is improving their own knowledge or transmitting newly acquired knowledge to their peers. Focusing on ordinary peers who receive information second-hand, who are the most representative farmers and therefore the preferred target of possible public programs in the future, we can further verify whether they acquire more knowledge when the information comes from an early adopter rather than from another ordinary peer.

Intervention

The digital platform, managed by the service provider Landfiles, has been customized for the experiment. In particular, participants do not have the possibility to share the content outside the platform, or even outside their peer group. In treatment arms A and B, only the injection points receive the information specially designed for the study; they can only share it with members of their group. treatment A and B differ because of the characteristics of the injection point, who will be an earlyt adopter of agroecology in arm A and an ordinary peer in arm B. In treatment C, the content is directly sent to all participants. Members of the same peer group can exchange with each other, but not with members of other peer groups.
Participants will receive a specific content on ecological practices, which we call the intervention. The content of the intervention will take the form of portraits of innovative farms, follow-up of agronomic trials, and newsletters. It will include several agroecological topics, including companion plants, plant cover, non-tillage associated with the reduction of herbicides, cereal-vegetable association, foliar fertilization. In practice, the injection points in arms A and B as well as each participant in arm C will receive one portrait of an innovative farm every two weeks, one agronomic trial follow-up every three weeks, and one newsletter every month.

Experimental design

We run a stratified randomized control trial (RCT) that include three arms: two treatment arms (A and B) and one control arm (C). The first strata includes farmers previously identified as early adopters. The second strata include ordinary peers. In the first phase of randomization, individuals are randomly assigned to the arms of the trial. Thereafter, we form peer groups of around ten farmers within each treatment arm. After peer groups are defined, we then randomly select injection points within peer groups of treatment arms A and B. In treatment arm A (resp., B), the injection point is randomly selected among early adopters (resp., ordinary peers) in each peer group. In the control group, no one is designated as an injection point (neither early adopters nor ordinary peers): information is delivered directly to all participants, as in a traditional broadcasting strategy.

Design details

Randomization method
Random assignment to the arms of the trial, as well as random selection of injection points among ordinary peers in treatment arm B will be performed using computer software.
Randomization unit
We will randomize individuals.
Clusters
Randomization is conducted at the individual level, not based on clusters.
Observations
847 farmers
Arms
283 individuals in treatment arm A, 282 individuals in treatment arm B, 282 individuals in the control group.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes measure participants’ access to information through user data automatically collected through the digital platform. These data includes information about user connections, viewing posts, reacting to posts, and reaction time to posts.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include scores of knowledge tests relating to the content distributed to the treated peer groups through the platform.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords