The Endowment Effect: High stakes evidence from rural Zambia
How to cite
Jack, B. Kelsey; Fehr, Dietmar; Fink, Günther. 2019. "The Endowment Effect: High stakes evidence from rural Zambia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001111. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1111-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A growing literature associates poverty with biases in decision-making. We investigate this link in a sample of over 3,000 small-scale farmers in Zambia, who participated in a series of experiments involving the opportunity to exchange randomly assigned household items for alternative items of similar value. Exploring a total of 5,842 trading decisions over a range of household items we show that exchange asymmetries are sizable and remarkably robust across items and experimental procedures. Using cross sectional, seasonal and randomized variation in financial resource availability, we show that exchange asymmetries decrease in magnitude when subjects are more constrained. Consistent with the interpretation that financial constraints increase decision stakes, we also show that trading probabilities increase when the value of the items involved is exogenously increased.
Intervention
We collect data in the context of an ongoing randomized controlled trial on seasonal resource constraints and labor supply that involved repeated surveys over multiple years (see Fink, Jack, and Masiye, 2018). As part of the ongoing surveys, households received a small item as a compensation for their time. We intervened in this standard procedure by randomly endowing participants with one of two equally-valued items midway through a survey. Items were common household necessities worth about 1/5th of the daily agricultural wage. At the end of the survey, surveyors offered participants the opportunity to trade the endowed item for the alternative item. This implements the standard exchange paradigm used to measure the "endowment effect" in laboratory settings in a more naturalistic, real-stakes decision in the field.
Experimental design
Trading decisions were measured over three survey rounds, implemented after the 2014 harvest, before the 2015 harvest (during the hungry season) and after the 2015 harvest, with random variation in respondent experience in each round. Item pairs and experimental procedures were varied at the village and household level, respectively, into the following conditions:
A) Item pairs:
i) Boom (washing powder) versus Salt
ii) Boom versus cash
iii) Cup versus spoon
iv) Solar lamp versus cash
B) Experimental procedures:
i) Free Choice (no initial assignment)
ii) Assigned (by computer)
iii) Lottery (transparent randomization)
iv) Timing (~5 min interval between assignment and trading opportunity)
v) Voucher (initial assignment of voucher instead of item)
vi) Expectations (trading opportunity announced at time of initial endowment)
vii) Wording (surveyor requested respondent to trade)
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Poor and Rational: Decision-Making under Scarcity Dietmar Fehr, Günther Fink, and B. Kelsey Jack Journal of Political Economy 2022 130:11, 2862-2897 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/full/10.1086/720466
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.