An Experimental Evaluation of Hot Spot Policing in Brazil

How to cite

Monteiro, Joana; Serrano-Berthet, Rodrigo; Pezzuchi, Gaston; Fagundes, Eduardo. 2023. "An Experimental Evaluation of Hot Spot Policing in Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011108. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11108-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Joana Monteiro* , Rodrigo Serrano-Berthet , Gaston Pezzuchi , Eduardo Fagundes

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011108
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11108-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-03-27 – 2024-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
K42
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11108

Abstract

This project is the first experimental assessment of preventive patrolling in Brazil. We partnered with Parana Military Police to design and test the effects of hot spots policing on crime in Curitiba, Brazil. We identified 557 hot spot street segments and randomly assigned 211 to receive more police visits over the intervention period and will compare this treatment effect against business-as-usual patrols at hotspots. It is hypothesized that more time spent at hotspots (i.e., 30 minutes) with two or more visits per day will cause more reduction in robberies and other crimes that take place on streets. We also use non-experimental streets to test for spillovers onto non-hot spots and examine aggregate effects citywide. This study will complement the scant literature on hotspot policing in Latin America which so far has shown limited impact. The intervention has started on March 27th 2023 and is planned to last until July 2023.

Intervention

We will run a hot spot policing program in the city of Curitiba, in Paraná state, Brazil, as part of a hotspot initiative promoted by IADB.

We will test both the effectiveness and efficacy of saturated policing plus POP interventions at hotspots: a randomized controlled trial in which treatment conditions will receive more police visits over the intervention period – while comparing this treatment effect against business-as-usual patrols at hotspots. It is hypothesized that more time spent at hotspots (i.e., 30 minutes) with two or more visits per day would cause more reduction in robberies: a dose–response relationship between police presence and the level of crime at the hotspot.

The officers were instructed to be visible and outside of their cars during patrol time and were encouraged to perform their law enforcement duties as normal (e.g. only to perform stops and frisks if there was reasonable suspicion to do so) and to talk to people while they were on patrol.

Experimental design

Hotspots segments were identified as the one in which at least three robberies (top 1% of segments distribution) were registered in a twelve-month period and meet one of the following conditions:

• It is part of a statistically significant spatial clusters, calculated through Getis-Ord Gi* statistic
• It is part of an emerging hotspot, according to Space Time Pattern Mining ArCGIS tool
• It is part of a cluster, defined using Nearest Neighbor Hierarchical Clustering

This leads to the identification of 557 hot segments.

We used a two-stage randomization to maximize similarity between treated and control segments. We first divided segments into five categories using Jenks natural breaks to determine five different levels of crime density (number of crimes divided by street length). Second, we assigned segments to treatment and control groups by category. We start by randomly selecting one segment to treatment group and then select a second one to control group. Street segments within 200 m of a treatment unit were excluded from the pool of potential controls to minimize contamination effects from treatment areas.

This randomization procedure assigned 214 hot segments to treatment and the same number to control group. These 428 segments account for 27.7% of the city’s reported robberies. To examine spatial spillovers, we also analyze the 7646 street segments that lie within 200 meters of the 428 segments.

We then aggregated treatment segments into groups in order to create clusters to receive patrol. This procedure led to the creation of 27 hot spot patrol routes. Often, these hot segments were not coterminous but were located close to each other. Patrol routes were designed by the police and avoid control segments.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in Python
Randomization unit
Street segment
Clusters
Total sample size is comprised by 7346 street segments. The treatment is not clustered.
Observations
We have two samples. An experimental sample of 422 hot segments and a larger sample of 6924 street segments that we will use to assess spatial spillovers.
Arms
The randomization procedure assigned 211 hot segments to treatment and the same number to control group. These 422 segments account for 27.7% of the city’s reported robberies. To examine spatial spillovers, we also analyze the 6924 street segments that lie within 200 meters of the 422 segments.
Primary outcomes
Number of robberies
Secondary outcomes
- Index of any criminal events that take place in public space and subdivide this index into property and violent crimes - Motor vehicle thefts and robberies - Illegal possession of firearms - Assaults in public space - Robberies inside buildings (commercial or residences)
Sponsors
Name: IADB Location: Washington, DC Url: https://www.iadb.org/en/citizen-security/citizen-security-and-justice
Partners
Name: Secretaria de Segurança Pública do Paraná Partner_type: government Url: https://www.seguranca.pr.gov.br/CAPE

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords