Caste And Religion Based Discrimination In Healthcare Delivery: Evidence From India

How to cite

Zutshi, Rushil. 2023. "Caste And Religion Based Discrimination In Healthcare Delivery: Evidence From India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011070. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11070-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rushil Zutshi*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011070
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11070-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-06-01 – 2023-08-31
Countries
India (Bihar)
JEL codes
Health and Economic Development
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11070

Abstract

Despite overall improvements in population health in India, there remain significant differences in health outcomes along caste and religious lines. Due to the lack of rigorous evidence, it is unclear if these differences stem from a lack of access to healthcare or discrimination at point of care. I use a randomized controlled trial to measure the discrimination faced by patients at point of care by private health care providers in Bihar, India. I use standardized patients (SPs) seeking care for asthma and randomly vary their religious and caste presentation to measure the causal effect of caste and religion on technical and interpersonal quality of care. SPs presenting as Muslims with religious indicators (such as eyeliner, a beard, and skullcap) received technical quality of care scores that were 0.29 standard deviations lower than upper-caste Hindu SPs and interpersonal quality of care scores that were 0.19 standard deviations lower than Hindu SPs. SPs presenting as Muslims without any religious indicators (only a Muslim name) or as Dalit (individuals of a lower-caste or without a caste) also received lower technical quality of care scores than upper-caste Hindu SPs but did not experience significantly worse interpersonal quality of care. I also find that, although minority providers provide better care to all patient types compared to Hindu providers, the disparity in healthcare quality experienced by minority patients was larger at minority providers. These finds suggest that differences in health outcomes among underserved minorities such as Muslims and Dalits are driven, in part, by discrimination at the point of care – often by providers of the same religious or caste identity. The results suggest that interventions such as implicit-bias training could help improve outcomes for these groups.

Experimental design

The primary aim of this study is to identify the discrimination faced by individuals based on their caste and religion. In India, caste and religion are usually gleaned by one's name and when applicable, by the way in which one presents oneself. As such, we designed an intervention that induces random variation in these attributes. We randomly vary SP roles across providers to estimate the effect of caste and religion of the patient on the healthcare they receive.

Each provider received a visit from one of four different SP types. Each SP type introduced themselves by name before the visit begins in order to signal their religion or caste. Type-1 SPs had an upper-caste Hindu name and were dressed in a well-ironed shirt and trousers. They introduced themselves by saying "Namaste" (the Hindi salutation most commonly used by Hindus in India). Type-2 SPs had a Muslim name and were also dressed in a well ironed shirt and trousers. Type-3 SPs also had a Muslim name (the same as Type-2) but they presented with certain religious indicators such as skull cap, a beard, and were wearing a kurta-pyjama. Both Type-2 and Type-3 SPs introduced themselves by saying Salaam (the Urdu salutation most commonly used by Muslims in India) Type-4 SPs had a Dalit name and were dressed in a more unkempt manner than the other SPs. This was only because, in the Indian context, caste is often (but not always) very closely correlated with class. Instead, caste is usually only displayed by physical religious indicators by those of the upper-castes (and even then, it is uncommon in most cities). Type-4 SPs also introduce themselves by saying Namaste.

Ten unique enumerators were selected from a larger pool of 16 actors to play the SP roles. Of the ten enumerators, five were Muslims and five were Hindu. The Muslim enumerators played both muslim roles while the Hindu enumerators played both Hindu roles but the Muslim enumerators did not play either Hindu role and vice versa. This was done to ensure the safety of the enumerators since religion and caste are very sensitive issues in India and if an enumerator was caught pretending to be someone of a different caste or religion, they may be mistreated. All the SPs presented with an identical case of asthma. This case of asthma was adapted from the cases developed by ISERDD in New Delhi (Institute for Socio-Economic Research on Development and Democracy) for the Quality of Tuberculosis Care (Qutub) Project. They were trained extensively over the week long training period. so that each role
was portrayed consistently across actors. This included memorizing answers to common questions
(e.g., “when did you last feel breathless?”, ”how long does an episode of breathlessness last?”, or “what were you doing when you last felt breathless?”) so that each
actor responds similarly for the respective role. We randomly assigned the SP role the providers receive (stratified by town) and further, randomly assigned the actors to play each role (within the Muslim and Hindu pools of enumerators). All SPs completed the visit and pay any fees required by the doctor. The standardized nature of the cases presented to the providers helps isolate the effect of the caste and religion (and visibility of religion) on healthcare delivery.

Design details

Randomization method
Office by computer
Randomization unit
Provider
Clusters
604
Observations
604
Arms
159 Hindu, 150 Dalit, 149 Muslims without religious indicators, 146 Muslims with religious indicators
Primary outcomes
Technical quality of care, Interpersonal quality of care

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords