The Gendered Impacts of Employment

How to cite

Kelley, Erin; Hussam, Reshmaan; Lane, Gregory. 2023. "The Gendered Impacts of Employment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011056. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11056-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Erin Kelley* , Reshmaan Hussam , Gregory Lane

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011056
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11056-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-01-23 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J16, D91, I31, J22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11056

Abstract

What is the relationship between employment and gender identity? We study this question in the context of the Rohingya refugee camps, the largest refugee camps in the world, and a setting in which pervasive unemployment and strong gender norms mark daily refugee experience. We involve 2520 individuals in a field experiment with four arms: a control arm, a weekly cash arm, and an employment
arm of equal value, and a volunteering arm. We explore how each of these interventions ultimately affects psycho-social wellbeing through their impacts on individuals' engagement of self (self worth, purpose), engagement with their partner (intra-household decision making, bargaining and intimate partner violence), and engagement with the outside world (sociability). By disentangling the key components of employment into receiving an income, performing a productive activity, and receiving an income for performing a productive activity, we are able to map the various dimensions of employment to distinct policy interventions, each with potentially distinct returns for males and females in our context.

Intervention

Our experiment implements three interventions. Relative to a control arm, in which individuals receive a nominal fee for weekly survey participation, we design an employment arm, in which we offer gainful employment in the form of surveying tasks for an average of four days per week for six weeks; a cash arm, in which we offer no work but the equivalent sum of money in the form of weekly cash transfers; and a volunteer arm, in which we offer an equivalent but unpaid work opportunity and a nominal fee for weekly survey participation. A comparison of the work arm to the control arm yields the value of employment in its entirety. A comparison of the work arm to the cash arm yields a causal estimate of the non-pecuniary value of employment. A comparison of the work arm to the volunteer arm enables a distinction between the psychosocial value of fulfilling the role of the ‘breadwinner’ of a family (working and earning for work) to that of the experience of working without earning. We enroll 2520 married couples into the experiment. While we offer a randomized treatment to only one member (male or female) of each couple, we survey both members, allowing us to document spillovers of each intervention on the spouses of treated individuals.

Experimental design

Our sample households spanned 280 sub-blocks, with each sub-block randomly assigned to one of the three experimental arms (80 blocks each) and a control group (40 blocks). Each household we selected was randomized into having the husband or the wife receive the respective intervention. Table \ref{baltable} reports summary statistics and balance across the arms. All households were informed that the study would last six weeks, with surveyors returning weekly to a pre-assigned meeting point to conduct five-minute surveys and provide compensation. In the 40 control sub-blocks, the selected wife or husband of the couple was informed that s(he) would receive 50 taka (USD \$0.50) as compensation for the weekly surveys. In the 80 cash sub-blocks, this individual was informed that s(he) would receive 1200 taka (USD \$12) as compensation for the weekly surveys. In the 80 work sub-blocks, the individual was offered an opportunity for gainful employment in which s(he) could work for an average of four days per week (either three or five) over the six weeks and be compensated 300 taka (USD \$3) per day of work, resulting in an average of 1200 taka (USD \$12) weekly; these individuals would also be asked to complete the weekly surveys. Lastly, in the 80 volunteer sub-blocks, the individual was offered an opportunity to engage in the same activity as those in the work arm, but for no pay, beyond the 50 taka (USD \$0.50) received as compensation for completion of the weekly surveys. The randomized nature of treatment allocation was made public to all participants, with surveyors displaying the participant's randomized treatment status on their tablet screen.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
We randomize at the sub-block level within the refugee camp
Clusters
The research team enlisted 2520 households across 10 camps (2E, 2W, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10, 17, 18, 19), with each camp apportioned into 4 to 7 blocks, and 14 to 42 sub-blocks, with the latter as our unit of randomization. Our sample households spanned 280 sub-blocks, with each sub-block randomly assigned to one of the three experimental arms (80 blocks each) and a control group (40 blocks). We selected nine households per sub-block. These households were recruited first through a random walk, in which the field team began near the center of a given sub-block, moved in a randomly selected direction, and proceeded to knock on doors and inquire about interest in participating in our study. Each household we selected was randomized into having the husband or the wife receive the respective intervention.
Observations
2520 households
Arms
The research team enlisted 2520 households across 10 camps (2E, 2W, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10, 17, 18, 19), with each camp apportioned into 4 to 7 blocks, and 14 to 42 sub-blocks, with the latter as our unit of randomization. Our sample households spanned 280 sub-blocks, with each sub-block randomly assigned to one of the three experimental arms (80 blocks each) and a control group (40 blocks). We selected nine households per sub-block. These households were recruited first through a random walk, in which the field team began near the center of a given sub-block, moved in a randomly selected direction, and proceeded to knock on doors and inquire about interest in participating in our study. Each household we selected was randomized into having the husband or the wife receive the respective intervention.
Primary outcomes
We collect measures of psychosocial wellbeing, which our PAP describes in more detail. We organize the underlying channels navigating this relationship into three broad buckets: how work shapes the perception of self, household interactions, and relationships with the outside world. Our PAP outlines how each of these outcomes is measured.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords