How much help shall we give to refugees? An online experiment on attitudes towards temporary protection and helping behaviours in the EU -- Second-wave survey

How to cite

Blasco, Andrea; Krawczyk, michal; Nohlen, Hannah. 2023. "How much help shall we give to refugees? An online experiment on attitudes towards temporary protection and helping behaviours in the EU -- Second-wave survey." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011053. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11053-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andrea Blasco* , michal Krawczyk , Hannah Nohlen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011053
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11053-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-03-09 – 2023-06-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11053

Abstract

This pre-registration analysis plan concerns the second wave of the study titled 'An online experiment on attitudes towards temporary protection of refugees and helping behaviours in the EU,' with initial registration in July 2022 (RCT ID: AEARCTR-0009682). As in the first wave, the second wave of this study investigates the Europeans’ attitudes towards temporary protection of refugees, evaluating how these attitudes vary with the demographic traits of the people displaced, reasons why they had to leave their country, and the rights covered under temporary protection (e.g., access to housing, medical care). It also evaluates the extent to which individuals can be persuaded to adopt more inclusionary attitudes towards refugees by being stimulated to take the perspective of a refugee or by reading narratives that give a refugee’s perspective. This document extends the analysis plan to the data from the second wave, including hypotheses and methods for analysing a new randomised belief-correction intervention and comparing results from the first and the second wave.

Experimental design

As in the first wave, we are interested in evaluating how individuals' attitudes toward refugee protection vary with demographics and other variables and how individuals can be persuaded to adopt more inclusionary attitudes towards refugees by taking or getting the refugees' perspectives; pre-analysis plan RCT ID: AEARCTR-0009682.

Here, we report the following additional research questions/testable hypotheses for the second wave:

1. Measuring changes in attitudes over time
2. Measuring the effectiveness of perspective-getting/taking interventions over time
3. Measuring the effect of belief-correction interventions

Design details

Randomization method
Computer randomisation.
Randomization unit
Same as in the first wave (individual respondents, clustered by country)
Clusters
We aim at 14,000 respondents from six countries, with demographic quotas; see first wave registration.
Observations
14,000 respondents
Arms
55 NUTS regions across 6 countries
Primary outcomes
As in the first wave, we use the following questions as outcome measures: DCE: - To measure individual preferences towards refugees and support for temporary protection, we ask study participants to choose between one or none hypothetical refugee situations in a choice experiment ("Please, compare groups A and B described in the table and indicate which of the two, if any, you would prefer to offer temporary protection in the EU."). We will repeat the question six times under different scenarios (see later). Perspective-taking/getting: - Attitudinal measure: To measure support for the protection of Ukrainian refugees in the current situation, we ask whether respondents agree or not with granting temporary work permits to Ukrainians ("Do you agree or disagree with granting displaced people from Ukraine temporary work permits?") - Behavioural measure: We also ask whether respondents are willing to send a short text supporting Ukrainian refugees (encouraging volunteering, making donations, or raising awareness) to be shared via Twitter ("Would you agree to write a short text to persuade people in [Country] to donate? We will share your message on our Twitter account (You can also edit our template)"). - To measure support for policies already in place, we ask whether participants support the European Council's decision to grant temporary protection to the Ukrainians ("do you support or do you oppose this decision?") and whether the EU should extend it ("Assuming the situation in Ukraine does not change much, do you think the EU should extend the temporary protection for Ukrainian people beyond March 23, 2024?") - We also measure individual support for Ukraine to join the EU ("To what extent do you agree or disagree with the statement: 'Ukraine is part of the EU family'"?). - We ask about what rights (housing, labour market, medical, ...) they would like to include in temporary protection. Belief-correction intervention: - We hypothesise that providing participants with official statistics about refugees (i.e., the fraction of adult women) will "correct" possible wrong perceptions about refugees. We measure the effect of the intervention by asking respondents whether they want to revise their guesses and by how much. - We measure the effect of belief correction on attitudes with a question about whether they perceive crime as being made better or worse by the presence of refugees from Ukraine (11-point scale).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords