Teaching Mental Health: Evaluating India’s Saharsh “Happiness Curriculum”

How to cite

Moorthy, Avinash; Carney, Kevin. 2023. "Teaching Mental Health: Evaluating India’s Saharsh “Happiness Curriculum”." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011029. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11029-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Avinash Moorthy* , Kevin Carney

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0011029
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11029-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-05-16 – 2025-05-01
Countries
India (Tripura)
JEL codes
I15; I250; I210; I280
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11029

Abstract

The Saharsh happiness curriculum will be implemented in grades 1-8 across Tripura public schools in the 2023-2024 and 2024-2025 school years. The curriculum consists of daily happiness classes, where students engage in mindfulness, storytelling with open-ended discussions, and reflective conversations and activities designed to help students experience happiness. This study would be the first to evaluate the effectiveness of a happiness curriculum, exploring its impact on student mental health, wellness, academic achievement, grit, self-control, and social networks. Further, this study will compare the benefits of the curriculum to the opportunity cost of reduced learning time and explore its mechanisms. In doing so, we seek to assess the value of one of the largest non-cognitive skills and socioemotional learning initiatives in the world, and its potential as a driver of improved youth mental health.

Intervention

The Happiness Curriculum consists of a daily 30 minute happiness class, delivered by class teachers at the start of each school day, made room for by shortening other classes. A typical class begins with a guided meditation, leading into a group activity. This daily activity rotates between categories including storytelling, reflective conversations, and a mindfulness-only day each week. This is followed by a class discussion, and finally, a mindfulness check-out. Teachers are trained by master trainers employed by the Labhya Foundation, and administer these sessions following handbooks. These were designed following the Clover Model of Youth Development created by Dr. Gil Noam at Harvard Medical School, and are adapted to the local context and the students’ specific grade. For example, grades 1-2 focus on the self including senses and emotions while grades 5-6 examine friendship, teamwork, trust, and communication.

Experimental design

The experiment will take place with students in grades 1-8 in 100 randomly-selected primary schools in the West Tripura school district. Randomization will occur within schools at the grade level, where grades will be either assigned to: (1) a control, (2) the full Happiness Curriculum or (3) a mindfulness-only condition.

(1) Control group. The control group will receive no form of the Happiness Curriculum. Instead, the teacher will provide an additional 30 minutes of teaching on standard subjects such as math, science, and language. Because the Happiness Curriculum displaces 30 minutes of class time, this is the relevant comparison to understand the curriculum’s effects. On the one hand, the curriculum could come at a learning cost, as it crowds out teaching time spent on traditional subjects. On the other hand, it could increase focus throughout the day, and improve mental health, creating potential learning gains. This design allows us to evaluate these hypotheses.

(2) The full Happiness Curriculum. The Happiness Curriculum is a socioemotional learning intervention developed by psychologists and education experts. It has two main components: guided mindfulness meditation sessions, and group activities such as storytelling and reflective conversations that vary daily. All grades participate in daily guided meditation to start their day.

(3) Mindfulness Only. To separate the effects of the two components of the curriculum, a third group of students will complete only the mindfulness component. They will start each day with a guided meditation, and will complete the once-a-week mindfulness-only sessions of the full curriculum, but will not take part in the other activities. Instead, they will devote the remaining time to teaching as usual, as in the control group. This allows us to measure whether the activities have additional value beyond a mindfulness-only option that is both less intrusive and has documented benefits for anxiety, depression, and self-control (Davis and Hayes 2012).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
School-grade
Clusters
4,000 students, with 5 students per grade per school (the cluster), for a total of 800 clusters.
Observations
4,000 students
Arms
400 control grades (2,000 students) 200 full Happiness Curriculum grades (1,000 students) 200 mindfulness only grades (1,000 students)
Primary outcomes
Our survey’s primary outcomes of interest span mental health, wellness, academic performance, and social networks.
Secondary outcomes
We will conduct 800 teacher surveys to measure secondary outcomes. This will include teacher attitudes toward the curriculum, comprehension, and mental health.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords