In this project, we study how gender gaps in hiring in a male-type environment vary depending on the use of “irrelevant” or “silly” interview questions, questions that are used in real-world interviews as ice-breakers or to get a general sense of an applicant’s personality, rather than being related to job-related skills or characteristics.
Intervention
In the project we study whether subjects acting as employers exhibit difference in their willingness to “hire” or “bet on” men vs. women subjects in a male-type task depending on the presence of “irrelevant” or “silly” interview questions.
Experimental design
Our design aims to measure the impact of “irrelevant” or “silly” interview questions on gender gaps in hiring.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization between the no-gender and gender-known treatments will be based on whether they sign up for stage 2 or stage 5. Those who sign up in any given stage are not allowed to sign up in subsequent stages. In stage 5 we will have both no-gender and gender-known – they will be between subject and randomized by computer.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the employer.
Clusters
For stages 2 and 5 the clusters will be equal to the number of employers. We plan to have 3000 employers. For stage 3 the clusters will be equal to the number of subjects. For stage 3 we plan to have 200 people.
Observations
The number of observations will be the number of employers or subjects.
Arms
We plan to have 1000 employers in our no-gender treatment and 2000 employers in our gender-known treatment. We will have about 50% of our employee pairs falling into the woman-performed-better treatment, with the rest falling into the other categories.
Primary outcomes
We collect the following primary outcomes:
- Willingness to pay for employees’ answers to “silly “application question: This is defined as the portion of a fixed payment employers are willing to pay to receive the considered employees’ answers to a known “silly” question.
-Gender gap in hiring: This is defined as the difference in likelihood that a man vs. woman is hired in a mixed-gender employee comparison pair, conditional on their relative performance in an earlier task.
Secondary outcomes
To identify questions that are appropriate for this analysis, i.e. do not carry information about employee quality, we also measure:
- Beliefs about ability from “silly” question answer: a subset of employers will be shown two answers to the same “silly” question and asked to select which one had the higher score on the payment-relevant task
- External beliefs about “silly” question validity: This is defined as whether external individuals in a separate survey believe the answers to the “silly” questions are valuable in predicting performance in the math task when mixed in with other standard interview questions.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.