The welfare effects of switching to sustainable farming
How to cite
Grimm, Michael; Luck, Nathalie. 2023. "The welfare effects of switching to sustainable farming." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0011004. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.11004-3.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The intervention provides information and two rounds of training on organic farming practices. The intervention is implemented as a randomised controlled trial (RCT). Whereas a first study has focused on the short term effects with respect to knowledge, perceptions, awareness and experimentation (Grimm and Luck, 2023), this study will take a longer horizon and focus an the adoption of organic farming practices, conversion from conventional to organic farming and the effects on farmers’ welfare conditional on adoption. Welfare will be measured through agricultural profits and revenue, nutritional security, subjective wellbeing and health. This study can rely on a four-wave panel data set (baseline, two midline and endline survey) and substantial qualitative field research.
Intervention
The intervention provided information and two rounds of training on organic farming practices.
After the baseline data collection, we invited the 20 interviewed farmers in each treatment village to participate in a three-day training on organic farming, with farmers receiving seven hours of training per day. Based on the insights from the theoretical framework, our training intervention addressed experience, beliefs and risks. It offered extensive information about the costs and benefits of organic farming practices and hands-on training to maximize the learning effect and minimize the risk of usage. Raising awareness, changing perceptions and implementation at the community level are intended to address social risks. The training provided farmers with an introduction to organic farming and included information on potential marketing channels. Particular emphasis was placed on practical activities such as making organic fertilisers and pesticides. The training was designed by AOI in cooperation with the research team from Germany. AOI, together with its institutional members (local NGOs), delivered the training, which was held in the villages to minimize travel time for respondents. The farmers received IDR 50,000 (around USD 3.5) for each day of the training (only if they attended) to cover any transport costs and to compensate them for potentially forgone earnings. A first round of training was rolled out at the end of March 2018 and completed in May 2018. On average, 17 farmers out of the 20 invited farmers attended each training day.
A second round of training was rolled out in July 2022 and completed in August 2022. We invited the same farmers, i.e. the treatment group, to the training as in 2018. The training was designed together with the Indonesian Soil Research Institute and trainers from two P4S centers with a focus on organic farming. P4S are self-help agricultural and rural training centers. These institutions are owned and managed by farmers. They exist in most districts in Indonesia and receive financial resources from the local government. During the training, trainers provided partly a refresher training of the first training. They further augmented the training by a discussion of soil management in organic farming and by training on soil tests. Based on the soil tests that each farmer could conduct for his or her own soil, trainers provided fertilizer recommendations according to organic principles.
Experimental design
We applied a three-stage random sampling design to select 1,200 respondents. In the first stage, we randomly selected 60 villages, 30 villages in Yogyakarta and 30 villages in Tasikmalaya. In the second stage, we randomly drew farmer group(s) in selected villages. Farmer groups in Indonesia function both as social group but also as task groups for government programmes and the allocation of subsidies.
In each village, we selected a minimum of one and a maximum of three farmer groups until the total number of registered farmer group members from the selected groups was equal to or larger than 60. We set the minimum to 60 members to ensure that a sufficient number of farmers would attend our information sessions (assuming that only a fraction of the members is interested) from which we drew our study participants. After identifying the farmer groups, the members of the selected farmer groups were invited to an information session on organic farming, which was held in their village. These information sessions served two purposes: (1) to facilitate self-selection based on initial interest in organic farming and the willingness to participate in farmer group events; and (2) to collect contact details on prospective respondents. The information sessions were run by AOI. In the third sampling stage, we randomly drew 20 farmers among the attendees of each information session. These 1,200 farmers, 20 from each of the 60 villages, constituted the respondents of our survey. If there were fewer than 20 attendees at the information session, we asked the farmer group head to nominate additional farmer group members.
The treatment was randomised at the village level and consisted of training on organic farming methods and principles. Farmers from groups in control villages did not receive any training. As baseline data was not available at the time of the randomisation, we used publicly available regional data for the stratification. Specifically, we stratified the sample according to urban and rural status and the reported size of agricultural land area per village. In Tasikmalaya, we used ‘travel distance to the district capital’ as an additional stratification criterion as this region is characterised by less developed infrastructure.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.