Procedural Decision-Making in Response to Complexity

How to cite

Arrieta, Gonzalo; Nielsen, Kirby. 2023. "Procedural Decision-Making in Response to Complexity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010977. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10977-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Gonzalo Arrieta* , Kirby Nielsen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010977
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10977-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-03-06 – 2024-01-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10977

Abstract

Individuals often change their decision-making in response to complexity, as has been discussed for decades in psychology and economics, but existing literature provides little evidence on the general characteristics of these processes. We introduce an experimental methodology to show that in the face of complexity, individuals resort to "procedural" decision-making, which we categorize as choice processes that are more describable. We elicit accuracy in replicating decision-makers' choices to experimentally measure and incentivize the choice process' describability. We show that procedural decision-making increases as we exogenously vary the complexity of the environment. This allows for procedural reinterpretations of existing findings in decision-making under complexity, such as in the use of heuristics.

Intervention

We exogenously vary complexity of decisions and measure choice processes.

Experimental design

We exogenously vary complexity of decisions and measure choice processes.

Design details

Randomization method
Individuals are randomized into treatments through oTree
Randomization unit
For the charity experiment: We randomize into treatments at the individual-level: Decision makers will face either simple or complex menus, and replicators will be matched to three decision makers from the same treatment. Since replicators are asked to guess 5 decisions per decision maker, for three different decision makers, we cluster standard errors at the replicator level. For the risk experiment: We randomize into treatments at the individual-level: Decision makers will face either 2-, 3-, or 10-outcome lotteries, and replicators will be matched to three decision makers from the same treatment. Since replicators are asked to guess 5 decisions per decision maker, for three different decision makers, we cluster standard errors at the replicator level. Replicators are further randomized to be in the "message" or "no message" treatment, which varies whether the replicator can see the DMs message or not.
Clusters
The design is not clustered, so each cluster is one participant. We recruit 500 Simple decision-makers, 500 Complex decision-makers, 333 replicators. We analyze the data clustering std. errors at the replicator level. For the risk experiment: We recruit 500 decision-makers for each of the three treatments for a total of 1500. Since we have to split replicators into message/no-message, we recruit 1000 replicators, so we have three replicators per DM, and for both {message, no message} treatments,. We analyze the data clustering std. errors at the replicator level. Attrition in the replicators sample can generate unmatched DMs, so we may recruit further replicators to cover all DMs if attrition is substantial.
Observations
500 Simple decision makers, 500 Complex decision makers, 333 replicators (same as cluster) For the risk experiment: 500 2-outcome DMs, 500 3-outcome DMs, 500 10-outcome DMs, 500 replicators with message, 500 replicators without message
Arms
500 Simple decision makers, 500 Complex decision makers, 333 replicators For the risk experiment: 500 2-outcome DMs, 500 3-outcome DMs, 500 10-outcome DMs, 500 replicators with message, 500 replicators without message
Primary outcomes
replication rates across treatments, by round
Secondary outcomes
message length and content, button clicks to get additional information in risk experiment, choices in risk experiment

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords