Strategic Participation in Protests: Evidence from Women´s Day in Chile

How to cite

Crozier, Agustina; Correa, Sofía; Pino, Francisco. 2023. "Strategic Participation in Protests: Evidence from Women´s Day in Chile." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010970. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10970-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Agustina Crozier* , Sofía Correa , Francisco Pino

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010970
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10970-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-03-01 – 2023-03-12
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D74, P00
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10970

Abstract

In economics and political science there is not enough agreement on when deciding whether or not to attend a peaceful protest, people behave as strategic complements or substitutes (that is, whether greater expected participation increases or decreases incentives to participate). Although most theoretical models assume strategic complementarity, recent evidence (Cantoni et. al., 2019) shows that in Hong Kong protests, students behave as strategic substitutes. Our hypothesis is that in contexts where potential participants are heterogeneous---or belong to different groups---it could happen that agents interact as complements with some people/groups, and as substitutes with others. This investigation seeks to study this phenomenon within the context of Women´s Day demonstrations in Chile. By conducting an online survey of female undergraduate students at two universities, we will measure initial intention to participate in Women´s Day protests. Then, using that same data we inform students of the expected assistance of different groups and measure the effects of changes in expectations of participation on final intention to attend the march. Therefore, allowing us to identify the degree of strategic substitutability or complementarity
in the decision to protest within contexts of heterogeneous agents.

Experimental design

The methodology of this investigation revolves around an online survey that will be implemented in 3 waves. This survey will be sent to all female undergraduate students of two Chilean universities: University of Chile and University Diego Portales. The survey consists of: a first wave where student´s basic information and intentions to participate in the march is collected; a second wave where information on expected assistance from different groups is delivered; and a third wave where information on final participation in the march is collected. Participation in the survey will be encouraged with prizes that will be raffled among the participants.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done automatically by the survey server (Qualtrics) once participants enter the second wave of the survey. The randomization is programmed to assign treatments in a roughly equal manner across all respondents within the randomization unit.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is by groups (defined by the dimension of heterogeneity chosen) and universities. For example, if the dimension chosen is political ideology, then randomization will be done within each group and university: Right and UCHILE, Center and UCHILE, Left and UCHILE, Right and UDP, Center and UDP, Left and UDP.
Clusters
As described above, the unit of randomization is by universities and groups. There are two universities that are participating in the experiment and 3 groups for each dimension. Therefore, the methodology involves 6 clusters per dimension.
Observations
According to tuition figures of the year 2021, the University of Chile has 34.526 undergraduate students, where 18.010 students (52.2%) declare to be women. On the other hand, the University Diego Portales has 12.651 undergraduate students, where if around 50% declare to be women then there would be 6.325 students that would be part of the target audience of this survey. Considering an average response rate for online student surveys of around 10%, then there would be around 2.433 participants/observations.
Arms
Considering the planned number of observations described above and both the randomization units and number of treatments the sample size would be: 2.433(number of participants) ÷ 6 (number of randomization units) ÷ 8 (number of possible treatments) = aprox. 50 people within each treatment arm and cluster.
Primary outcomes
Given the chosen dimension(s) of heterogeneity, we have the following specific objectives: 1. Determine the degree of substitutability or strategic complementarity at a global level. That is, to study whether a greater total participation decreases or increases incentives to participate in the march. 2. Determine the degree of strategic substitutability or complementarity with one´s own group. 3. Determine the degree of strategic substitutability or complementarity with other different groups. 4. Depending on the number of participants achieved in the study, ordered dimensions of heterogeneity could be defined. In this case, it is intended to understand: a. What is the distance between two people (on the ideological scale or income level, as appropriate) from which the degree of substitutability or complementarity reverses? b. How does this distance vary across groups?

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords